Social Concerns Notes – August 2011

Where does one find information on Social Concerns?  One way is to talk with people.  But it is not possible to cover a whole nation or even two that way, so one turns to the newspapers and the blog sites.  We are indebted to Bill Standish for his work on this.  Having downloaded the material one always has to query the perspective and bias of the writer.  I try to select as best I can. I have some sense of what is happening in PNG, but unfortunately that is not the case with the Solomon Islands, so I would need assistance in that regard. I try when I can to provide the source for each article included in these notes.

For those fortunate few with good internet connections, useful URLS include the following.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/
http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/
http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php

http://www.pngblogs.com/
http://asopa.typepad.com/
http://www.actnowpng.org/
http://masalai.wordpress.com/
http://bougainville.typepad.com/
http://malumnalu.blogspot.com/
http://pngexposed.wordpress.com/

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/
http://lngwatchpng.blogspot.com/

http://www.islandsbusiness.com/islands_business/
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/
http://www.smh.com.au/
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/

http://www.eurekastreet.com.au/

http://www.postcourier.com.pg/

http://www.thenational.com.pg/

http://www.solomonstarnews.com/

Bank: 90% lack accountsThe National 1 August 11

GOVERNOR of Bank of Papua New Guinea Loi Bakani says more than 90% of people in Papua New Guinea do not have access to commercial accounts because of the difficult geographical locations. He said most of these people lived in remote places and travelled long distances to the nearest commercial centres, banks or post offices to cash money. “We would like to encourage what is called financial inclusion through the use of available telecommunications technology nationwide,” Bakani said. He said one of the BPNG’s visions was to get financial services to the rural people and make their lives easier and more manageable. He said Post PNG had made that possible through the launch of its new mobileSMK (Salim Moni Kwik) service where customers could now use their mobile phones to send or receive money from loved ones wherever they may be. “BPNG has welcomed the initiative and encourages that we come up with more partnership approach to improve lives in rural areas,” he said. He said the next phase of the project would be to launch it internationally or have the money transferred on mobile phones from a person in PNG to a relative or friend in another country. “It is good for those who want to avoid fine or fees or higher charges by commercial banks,” Bakani said.

PNG corruption watchdog says commitment to UN treaty had little impact to date. http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=62194 accessed 3 Aug

An anti-corruption watchdog in Papua New Guinea says membership of a UN treaty battling corruption hasn’t achieved much so far. The local chairman of Transparency International, Lawrence Stephens, says PNG is still amongst the saddest cases of countries viewed as corrupt, despite being the first Pacific Island state to sign the United Nations Convention against Corruption four years ago.Mr Stephens says cabinet still needs to approve a national corruption strategy based on the convention.

Momis encouraged Bougainvilleans
http://bougainville.typepad.com/ accessed 3 Aug

ABG President Chief John Momis is calling on Bougainvilleans to work together to take up steps that will empower them economically. He said most times people criticized the government for not providing services like education, health and roads but the government has no money available to provide these services. He added monies given by the National government to ABG it’s totally inadequate and cannot provide for the services needed. Mr Momis said funds also given by the Australian government, European Union plus others including the Japanese government in building bridges in Bougainville are highly appreciated but also not enough.
Chief Momis urged Bougainvilleans to break the chain of dependency syndrome to be free and not to ask for money all the time. Mr Momis said people in Bougainville must work together for a common goal that is to develop Bougainville.

Garasu Honoured
http://bougainville.typepad.com/ accessed 3 Aug

The Australian Government has this afternoon awarded Sr Loraine Garasu of the Nazareth Rehabilitation Centre in Chabai, Honor of Australia Award which is bestowed only to Australian citizens. The special award was presented at the Bougainville Administration Conference room by the Australian High Commissioner to PNG, Ian Kemish. In presenting the award, High Commissioner Kemish said that the people of Australia do recognize the work of Sr. Loraine in promoting rehabilitation and reconciliation through her work throughout the years.
In response, Award recipient, Sr Loraine said that she first did not want to accept the award but had to accept the award after talking to many people about it. She said that her work is to work with simplicity and not to ask for any reward as her reward for her work is awaiting her in heaven.In  March 2009, Sr Loraine received the US State Department’s international women of courage award.

Villagers relocated by Bougainville Copper suffer most says peace advisor

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201108/s3285078.htmaccessed 4 Aug

A leading academic and adviser to the Bougainville Autonomous government says the communities who have suffered most from the Rio Tinto owned Panguna copper mine are those that were relocated from villages at the mine site or from sites affected by mine tailings.
Landowners from the 6 mine lease areas are now going through a process to set up representative organisations to negotiate with the Rio Tinto subsidiary, Bougainville Copper Limited.
Anthony Regan: One of the reasons the landowners wanted to have separate associations for each lease area was because there are special needs, quite distinct needs, in each area and this issue alone indicates how different the needs are in the villages in the special mining lease as opposed to those in the lower tailings lease. So it will be a matter for each association to carefully document the needs and the problems of the people within their lease area and bring those to the table through the umbrella association but, in the process of setting up the associations, the Autonomous Bougainvlle Government, of course, is getting a tremendous window, on the issues that are facing the people, because in these long and detailed consultations the administration is having with the people, their problems are being put right on the table. I was in the tailings lease the special mining lease, in a series of meetings and the people are very clear, they know what their problems are and they are identifying them with tremendous clarity and great emotion. They really feel they have suffered, they are aware that they are the real victims of mining, and they are not opposing mining, for the future for the most part, but they are saying if it is to happen again, then it has to be done very differently and they, amongst others, have to be looked after in very different ways.
hopes of receiving that $40 million soon, are fading.

Ramu mine delivers empty tanks and empty promises

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 4 Aug

When the people of Ganglau and Mindre villages agreed to the industrialization of their land at Basamuk, Madang Province, they thought they would get;

  • Good Health care
  • A Primary School
  • Road linkage to Madang Town
  • Water supply
  • Power supply
  • Business opportunities
  • Employment opportunities

The people had good reason to believe that they would enjoy the above benefits as they were promised by the government and miners. Unfortunately, there has been very little progress.

The township that houses Chinese workers has been built in the catchment area of a nearby creek that provided drinking water for Mindre villagers. Sewerage from the township is drained into the creek. The creek has lost its flow and is slowly dying. Fish and eels that once inhabited the creek are gone. Today the villagers of Mindre have to walk about 3 Km to the Yaganon River, to bathe, do their laundry and fetch drinking water. The miners have set up one tank per village, which they connected to their water mains. However, a dispute with the company over monthly fees has meant that nothing flows into the tanks. The people do not want to pay the company for water which they say is being extracted free by the company.

PNG think tank says corruption fighting agencies need more resources

http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=62240 accessed 5 Aug

The head of an independent policy think tank in Papua New Guinea says the police are desperately under-resourced to deal with corruption and need the banking sector to play its part in stopping illegal transactions. The Institute of National Affairs’ director, Paul Barker, says the police’s Financial Intelligence Unit only has a handful of staff and the new government needs to allocate more resources to halt money laundering and financial fraud with public funds.

He says the banks and police must work together to avoid banking becoming a bottle neck to the country’s growing commerce.  “The rules have been to some extent announced by the police, the banks feel that it’s just been a burden thrust on them without consultation and hopefully over the next week or two there’ll be some sort of dialogue that will be opened up.”

Highlands tagged red-zone by police The National 5 August

THE highlands region is tagged the red zone as far as election-related violence is concerned, according to Police Commissioner Tony Wagambie. That is part of the reason the Electoral Commission and the Royal Papua New Guinea Constabulary held a conference this week to discuss key issues to ensure free and safe election. Based on the 2012 election theme on “free, safe and fair election without fear, harassment and intimidation”, other issues discussed at the conference included;
– Security for LNG project site;
– Election dates and logistics;
– Bribery, fraud and corruption;
– Hela and Jiwaka boundary issues;
– Charges to be laid against election-related violence offenders;
– Providing opportunity for people with disabilities to vote;
– Health issues include HIV/AIDS, chole­ra, tuberculosis and water safety;
– Drug and alcohol;
– Women and gender; and
– Security force training.
“Citizen’s attitude and behaviour warrant security. Therefore advance planning to ensure a free, secure and fair election is critical,” Wagambie said.

Women mistreated in logging areaPost Courier 5 Aug 11, feature

Women working at an oil palm plantation in East Pomio are mistreated, paid meagre wages and subjected to sexual assaults, a women leader has claimed. Executive Officer for Wide Bay Conservation Association, Elizabeth Tongne condemned the situation saying our women were being abused by foreigners and called for government intervention. “There is a rise in unwanted pregnancies in the area which again becomes another responsibility for the parents and the community,” she said. “When they get pregnant, then that’s when people start asking questions but usually it is not revealed because culturally rape is something that is not discussed.
“There is also wide circulation of pornographic materials.” She said underage schoolgirls are also victims. She said foreigners are luring them to have sex for money. She said most of the women were forced to work for meagre wages because their land had been taken away and food gardens destroyed. Their only hope to feed their families was to work for the company.

PNG TI warns of social unrest  (accessed 8/8/11)

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201108/s3288352.htm

Transparency International PNG says it fears there’ll be social unrest in the country if some highly anticipated legislation is not passed before next year’s general elections.

They include the creation of 22 reserved seats for women in parliament and the creation of two additional constituencies of Hela and Jiwaka in the highlands.

President of Transparency PNG, Lawrence Stephens said this while commenting on the sudden change of government in PNG.

One wonders whether they’re actually going to be able to deliver on these things. Clearly the women’s groups are hoping to see this law go through the parliament, but in past experience, when people are deciding the priorities of the parliament, they tend to put something’s last and that seems to have been one of the things that drops off the agenda each time things come up. The new electorate are extremely important, in particular, the new electorate of Hela, because many people who are looking at this as an opportunity for decisions to be brought closer to the people, power to be distributed in other ways and we can expect all sorts of social unrest if things are not handled quickly and carefully. The Jiwaka province is also a potential worry. So these things are all hanging over us. But unfortunately, the reality for Papua New Guinea is that we have many things hanging over us and tend to postpone the important decisions and important actions until things break apart in front of us. We’ve seen this in the past. We had it, for example, with Bougainville many things that needed to be done, that should have been done, that could have been done and simply people didn’t get around to doing their job or parliament was to busy looking at other issues.

From The National Editorial Aug 10, 2011

Yes, there is a multitude of issues crying out to be heard, addressed and resolved but is the period between now and polling day sufficient time to do that? Hardly. Some of those issues on the laundry list include seeing through public investigation into the use of public funds such as the commission of inquiry into the Special Agriculture and Business Leases (SABL), the K125 million worth of treasury bills used to fund development in Kokopo, the probe into alleged corrupt practices at the Department of National Planning and the mooted law changes to accommodate reserved women’s seats in parliament. The elephant in the room is the LNG project and the surrounding landowner equity issues as well as the establishment of two new provinces in Hela and Jiwaka. One would speculate that the real reason for such an abrupt change of government is simply to wrest control of the national purse strings in order to all but guarantee a return to power post-election. This may be a crude and simplistic outlook but the stark reality is that this how elections are won and lost in PNG.

Social welfare will cost PNG K420m The National – Wednesday, August 10th 2011
THE national task force on social protection says it will cost more than K400 million annually to run nationwide social protection services for children, the elderly and people with disabilities.
At a consultative forum on social protection last week in Port Moresby, the task force and stakeholders estimated the K420 million annual costs based on the income per person per household approach. Wrondimi said stakeholders that included government agencies, provincial representatives, including donor and development partners, had suggested four sources of funding for the social safety network in the country. “There were suggestions that the government should meet the costs outright through the sovereign wealth funds, or having joint partnerships between national government and provincial governments, including other partners so that it becomes a shared responsibility. “Another suggestion was to have contributions from the national and provincial government, including the members of parliament through the District Services Improvement Programme (DSIP) funding,” Wrondimi said.

‘10,000 refugees in PNG’Post Courier 10/8/11
WHILE Australia continues to deal with the problem of “boat people”, Papua New Guinea’s situation remains somewhat behind the curtains but it carries a fair share of concern.
JRS (Jesuit Refugee Service) Australia, an international NGO, revealed that Papua New Guinea hosts about 10,000 refugees. Most of these refugees reside in Western Province which shares a border with West Papua, including some who were moved there after arriving in West Sepik Province, which lies to the North of Western Province. From the total, about 3,000 of the West Papuan refugees agreed to reside in a relocation centre called East Awin in Western Province and as a consequence, were given Permissive Residency Permits, granting them conditional freedom of movement and allowing them to engage in business activities, enrol in PNG schools and tertiary institutions and access health facilities.  However, other remaining refugees are spread in villages close to the Indonesian border or in different towns throughout PNG, and have not been granted the benefits given to their counterparts in East Awin. One organisation working with JRS in the province is the Diocese of Daru-Kiunga. The diocese has a plan whereby refugee villages are seen as part of Catholic parishes where they receive help from the Catholic Diocese.

Oil palm sucking up soil minerals: Survey   Post Courier 10/8/11

BASELINE data collection into the impact of oil palm in New Britain Island has revealed that the crop has a tendency to absorb all minerals from the soil once it is planted. The survey was carried out in June in Wide Bay area of East Pomio through an Integrated Agriculture Training Program from the University of Natural Resource and Environment, formerly known as the Vudal University. Database and Information Administrator, Leo Darius said that clear felling of large areas of forests made up of premium species of wood to plant oil palm would greatly affect the environment because it would take approximately 20 – 30 years to replant those trees after oil palm is killed off. “Their roots are still firmly stuck into the soil, making it hard for any other plant or tree to be planted after it is killed off,” he said. He said the use of artificial fertiliser, which was usually the case, was having adverse effect on the water system and eventually into the open seas because in most instances, it would drain into the water system and eventually be transported out to sea to affect the marine and water life. “These areas need to be investigated further for the betterment of our environment,” he said. He was speaking in light of oil palm development currently underway in both East and West Pomio.

Hope for category ‘C’ schools
Post Courier 12 Aug

THEY belong to category ‘C’, a term in the language of education in Lae that means they are located in the squatter settlements.
In academic terms, they are at the lower end of the scale when it comes to getting curriculum materials and resources for their education. Around 7,000 children are lumped into this category of education.
Their teachers live in some of the worst teachers housing found anywhere and their classrooms are overcrowded. The classrooms are so old, nearly all of them have never been replaced for more than 30 years. 
There is no reliable water supply system and no proper sanitation system. There is no money in the bank account to pay for new books and resources for teachers to use in teaching. 
Nearly 100 per cent of the parents whose 700- plus children go to Haikost Primary School on the fringes of the notorious 2-Mile area of Lae City are unemployed.
Headmasters have chosen not to pursue unpaid school fees – they just let the children into class and get on with the job of teaching.
There are nine other primary schools in this category.
Being in category ‘C’ means they lack most of the very basic teaching and learning resources. 
All these schools have no school library and their teachers struggle to find teachers manuals to teach.
Yesterday – one week after the 2011 National Book Week – help arrived at Haikost Primary School. The Rotary Club of Lae arrived with a donation of books, desks and chairs for this school.
The Rotary Club of Lae has made a historic decision and committed itself to helping the category ‘C’ schools in Lae over the next five years. The club is committed to finding help for them no matter how long it takes.
Mr Miria urged the children to commit themselves to their education and work hard.

Forestry report launched
Post Courier 15 August.

Papua New Guinea’s forestry sector contributes K400 million to the PNG economy, but sadly, suffers high levels of illegal logging as a consequence of weak legislation.
Transparency International Papua New Guinea (TIPNG), revealed this on Friday at the launch of the Forest Governance Integrity Baseline Report Papua New Guinea 2011.
PNG prides itself with 22 million hectares of forest. However, ongoing exploitation of these forests not only threatens the livelihood of 80 per cent of Papua New Guineans in rural areas who rely on the forests for their livelihood, but also threatens the country’s rich biodiversity.
Forest Governance Integrity Program manager, Michael Avosa, said between 2004 and 2006, there has been a high turnover of reports about illegal logging activities in PNG.
“Corruption cannot be separate from bribe. The two walk hand in hand,”

Well done, Electoral Commission
Post Courier 15 Aug.

Dear Papua New Guinea Electoral Commision, I salute you for two things.
Firstly for separating women voters from men voters in Kundiawa Gembolg by-election in the Chimbu province.
 Secondly, for electronic counting and double checking of the votes. 
May I suggest five more issues that will completely stop corrupt practices during election;
* Use a better and proven indelible ink that can not be washed off by any detergent from the shops. 
* Do “whole finger” dipping and not just marking the finger nail.
* Push to gazette the polling days as public holidays in PNG so no one has an excuse not to vote during working days.
* Voters should use some form of ID Cards such as drivers license, passport, work ID (from IPA registered companies, churches, NGOs, etc). Those who do not have any form of identification cards should ask the registered organisations to issue them promptly while we have the time.

New govt must address social imbalances
 Post Courier 15 Aug

While I congratulate the new Government for making a stand to fight corruption and charge those involved in misusing billions of public funds.
Please leaders, honour your words with your actions.
Citizens, be proud of our country, do not fall prey to discriminate remarks on PNG, 
Look at what is happening in western countries like the riot in London, UK, so called civilized society, billions of dollars worth of properties including shops, buses, were damaged, shops looted, Imagine, if this is happened in Port Moresby, how many countries would have released travel warnings, especially our neighbour, so we should be proud of our country, at least with the minimum resources we still could run our country.
Another example is the downgrading of US treasury bills from AAA to AA, at least the PNG Bills are still reliable and sure to be honoured for its returns. 
Believe in PNG, we will progress. I request the new governmentt to look at social imbalances within our capital city, as an ordinary citizen currently cannot afford to own or rent a decent residence.
The truth is that most of the properties in Port Moresby, be it commercial or residential, are all owned by foreigners or foreign companies.
When can we have some equality and as an ordinary citizen of this country, own something in our own land? 
Can we do some thing about it and regulate the property market in the country. 

Naturalized Citizen

Participatory Video on Conservation from the Solomon Islands

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgTqt4qbLhg&feature=player_embedded#at=61

This is a great short movie about conservation in Solomon Islands. From the blurb: “Conservation Story Blong Chivoko” was made by the men and women of the remote coastal village of Chivoko, accessible only by sea on the north-west tip of Choiseul Island, one of the Solomon Islands. Chivoko’s tribal land is one of the last remaining intact and unlogged forests in the Solomon islands. Their reefs are important spawning sites for the grouper fish which come to lay their eggs every year for 2 months around May. Their story is an insight into the problems they are facing with increased pressure from logging companies, increasing population, declining forest and marine resources, and ensuing climate change. They provide solutions which may help other Solomon Island and other communities around the world, to also safeguard the abundance of resources for future generations to come…

Child sexual abuse rampant, says judge.  National 16 August 11

Cases of child abuse and violence against children are becoming widespread in the country, a situation that is said to escalate school drop-out rates, sespcially among girls, Goroka-based acting judge Martin Ipang said yesterday.   Ipang said: “Most incidents of child abuse are carried out by familiar people, including close relatives such as uncles, cousins, bubus and even step-parents. “It is probably this factor that explains why many cases go unreported, withdrawn from police and the courts.  People woud rather keep quiet and shield an abuser, than report him or her, just for the sake of th so-called ‘necessity of protecting family reputation or family ties’,” he said….

Profiting from ‘disaster capitalism’? The National – Thursday, August 18th 2011

NCD Governor Powes Parkop is right to challenge the government’s proposal to reopen the asylum centre in Manus (The National, Aug 15). It is impetuous of Australia to have us believe that the problem of asylum-seekers is a regional issue and the Manus centre is a partnership between PNG and Australia to address this issue. This so-called partnership consists of nothing more than Australia funding the detention centre and PNG providing the location and a band-aid solution to Australia’s problem. In reality, PNG is not particularly worried about the boat people but supports the partnership because it sees the detention centre as a way to boost Manus’ stagnating economy. Profiting from the misery of others is the odious principle underlying “disaster capitalism”, the idea that profit rather than humanitarian concern should be the motive behind disaster ma­nagement. The concept also applies to Australia’s asylum seeker detention centres, which in some cases, are run by multi-nationals such as British firm Serco. The PNG government and the centre’s proponents, particularly Manus Governor Michael Sapau, need to ask themselves this: Will they reopen the centre if there is nothing to gain? Are they supporting the centre for genuine humanitarian reasons or are they profiting from human mi­sery?

Deni Tokunai,New Zealand

IFC cannot shut project  Post Courier 19 Aug 11

THE International Finance Corporation (IFC) has advised that while it can try and facilitate dialogue between the government and landowners on issues regarding the Pacific Marine Industrial Zone (PMIZ), it cannot shut the project.
Speaking during a meeting at Rempi village, just outside Madang, with the landowners from the impact areas of the PMIZ project Vice President-Compliance Advisor Ombudsman-IFC Meg Taylor said she was in the country to attend to the complaint which had been filed by the villagers.
Ms Taylor said the role of her office was to deal with complaints and all those she had dealt with involved companies.
She said this was the first time this office had received one involving government.
She said while the complaint was different, it was also important and during her short visit in the country, her job would be to meet with government, the landowners and the company and to try and bring everyone to a roundtable to try and find a way forward.
“I am here now as an international public servant to hear your problems,” she said.
 
She said the complaint had resulted in her making the trip to PNG.

Malabag backs wage increase  Post Courier 19 Aug 11

PNG Trade Union Congress president Michael Malabag said the union movement is happy and endorses the new Minister for Labour and Industrial Relation’s statement this week to increase the national minimum wage.
Mr Malabag agreed that certain companies are not complying and paying their workers less than the minimum wage rate set of K2.29 hourly agreed on in 2008.
He said although the Employers Federation is complying, certain companies that are not members are not paying Papua New Guineans according to the rate.
Mr Malabag said these companies are mostly from the logging, agriculture and fisheries sector.
“These companies are not members of the Employers Federation and therefore do not feel obligated to pay,” Mr Malabag said.
He said the department needs to take action on these companies.

The climate refugees of the Carteret Islands  Asopa.typepad.com

THE CARTERET ISLANDS in Papua New Guinea are not on most maps of the Earth; they’re just too small to merit inclusion at one square kilometer of total land mass spread among a cluster of coral atolls. But they just might make it big in the history books — as the former home of the world’s first true climate refugees. “The Carterets lie in a circular reef infringed by many reefs in a lagoon, very beautiful but going down really fast through shorelines degradation,” reports Ursula Rakova, a local resident. “Over the last 20 years, [the] Carterets have been experiencing rising sea levels, and our chiefs got together and initiated an organization which could fast-track our relocation.” The islanders may have made a bad situation worse by fishing with dynamite, destroying protective reefs in the quest for food after refugees flooded the islands during Bougainville’s war to secede from PNG in the 1990s. The 1,700 or so Carteret islanders may be among the first people to move. That’s because scientists estimate the islands will be drowned by 2015.

Time frame short for women’s bill Post Courier 23/8/11     

FORMER Minister for Community Development and member for Moresby South Dame Carol Kidu is of the opinion that the women’s bill will not make it through before the 2012 elections.
She said although NEC endorsed it and had the some backing, the time frame was very short.
Dame Carol said so much effort has been put into the women’s bill and the general perception that it is a foreign agenda is wrong. The former minister said she has been accused of bringing foreign agenda into PNG but there are a lot of foreign agendas already in the country, including Christianity. When giving a very brief account of her experiences of her campaign and her overview of the challenges women candidate face during campaigning and elections, she told women trainers at a women candidate training workshop in Port Moresby yesterday that the task now is to use the training and go ahead to train women for elections next year.

 Natschol in, OBEoutThe National – August 24th 2011

NATIONAL scholarship for tertiary students will be reintroduced by January next year, Prime Minister Peter O’Neill said yesterday. Among sweeping changes the government is introducing for the education sector under its free education policy: The controversial outcomes-based education (OBE) would be scrapped by January; Government to pay all tuition fees for students from elementary to Grade 10; Government to subsidise 75% of fees for Grades 11-12; No drop-outs at Grade 8; and Payment of K350 million into a special trust held by the Education Department by November this year for distribution to all schools by January.

PNG gets low literacy ratingThe National – Wednesday, August 24th 2011

PAPUA New Guinea is placed at 148 out of 182 countries in a United Nations listing on national literacy rates, National Literacy Awareness Secretariat Willie Jonduo says. He said according to census 2000, of the six million people, “43.8% are illiterate”. “These statistics are alarming because when PNG is compared with the rest of the countries in the world, using the United Nations human development index, its placing is 148th out of 182 listed countries,” he said.

PNG landowners risk being swindled under proposed mining law

http://www.radioaustralianews.net.au/story.htm?id=43410   24 Aug 2011

A senior academic says landowners will need proper legal representation and guidance if Papua New Guinea introduce proposed changes to the country’s mining laws. The PNG government is reviewing existing laws to revert ownership of resources under the land and seabed to the traditional owners. Professor Spike Boydell from Sydney University of Technology’s Asia-Pacific Centre for complex real property rights welcomes the move to make compensation for landowners more equitable. But he says there’s a risk they won’t be properly advised when dealing with mining investors. BOYDELL: I think a bill like this is very important yes to the mineral rich countries in Melanesia and I know that certainly Fiji with its resources in gold, copper and bauxite. The Solomon Islands recent discovery of reserves in nickel will be looking at this very, very closely. Now obviously some of those states have seen their future in the economic prosperity from their share of mineral resources. One thing we have to remember is that the government hasn’t always seen the most financially viable deal being struck. Now the same could said of customary landowners if they’re not properly represented, but if there is proper representation and the provisions are put in place, then those other countries which will be looking at this very, very closely will find themselves in a situation where they may actually benefit and their customary landowners may actually benefit as well from this sort of initiative.

 PNG loses under current ModelPost Courier 29.8.11    

The PNG LNG Project Business Model is based on existing business, models for oil and mineral development in PNG. Under this model, the State, Provincial Governments and landowners are to participate only at the upstream, by exercising their 22.5 percent rights under the Oil and Gas legislation. Other than that they have no participation or interests in other segments of the Project. Under the current Business Model, the State and the landowners are complete bystanders, with no tangible control and ownership in the Project. This Business Model defeats original Government policy ambition as well as political and economic aspirations of PNG.
The ultimate benefactors of the PNG LNG Project are the developers. As a result, the LNG project will not underpin the economic advancement of PNG. Almost 80 percent of direct revenue from the project will flow out of PNG. No doubt, with current disagreements coupled by landowner related issues and concerns as well as hired workers’ in the various aspects of the Project, people will be demanding a review of the whole agreement and related provisions.

Land Owner threatens to shut down school – Post Courier 30.8.11

THE principal landowner of Notre Dame Secondary School in Western Highlands Province has threatened to close the school for good.
John Doa, who claimed to be the principal landowner, said the parties had early this year met and discussed with the Lands Department and agreed to a compensation payment for the land but no payment had been made so far.
He said the Western Highlands Provincial Government, Provincial Administration, Notre Dame Administration and the Provincial Education must come together to meet his cost that he had spent to battle for the land payment.
Mr Doa called on the Western Highlands Provincial Government to repay his K40,000 with interests.

Solomon Islands could relapse into turmoil within weeks if RAMSI is withdrawn

Solomon Star  31st August, 2011

The Sydney Morning Herald reported that despite the massive aid effort, US officials have approvingly quoted the assessment of key diplomatic contacts in Honiara that if RAMSI departs ”it would only take about a week for trouble to break out again since RAMSI and the Government has failed to address the underlying issues [which caused widespread ethnic violence]. “There are still people out in communities who have not been brought to justice for atrocities committed during the ethnic conflict. These incidents and the economic tensions … continue to fester. As is clear to every observer, over the 28 years since independence, modern government has failed to take firm root,” it was reported.

PNG’s National Repentance Day: reflections of an absurdity  30.08. 2011

http://dreamzmedia.wordpress.com/category/what-were-they-thinking/

A national day of repentance has to be one of the most ludicrous excuses for a public holiday ever thought up. It is an unnecessary waste of time and is yet another excuse for a country with a largely lazy urban population to become even lazier. Whether Biblically speaking or even in a general context, the notion of repentance in a person comes from deep within. Even though influencing factors may be largely external, the conviction that drives a person to alter their lifestyle, change their habit or even to take on a completely new persona stems from deep within the recesses of their conscience through a change of their mindset.

True repentance is a deeply personal matter that will in no way be achieved through any means of coercion or compulsion, much less through the establishment of a public holiday. In fact having this public holiday is a clear case of that popular adage of taking a horse to the river but never getting it to drink. There were no horses last weekend but I can assure you there were a lot more people consuming an insanely copious amount of that amber ale at every tucker box or trade store that happened to be selling it. This is a clear indication of the fact that having this day set aside as a public holiday in essence has robbed it of its significance.

If anything, Repentance Day screams of nothing but religious pomposity. It has all the hallmarks of the workings of what can be compared to that of the Pharisees. A vainglorious attempt by parliamentarians to make them feel good in the eyes of the largely Christian populace; perhaps to get the rest of the Papua New Guineans to share in the guilt of missing one too many parliamentary sittings. What is befuddling to any sane person out there is that Papua New Guinea already has a National Prayer Day which can be put to the same purpose as this so-called Repentance Day without the need for a public holiday. Why can’t we work from there on?

In fact Papua New Guinea already has 4 days of Easter, a day in Christmas in remembrance of the birth of our Lord and of course, New Year’s day, a day widely associated with new resolutions. Throw in 51 Sundays and another 52 Saturdays (Sabbaths) and we arrive at the magic number of 109 days.

That is 109 holidays in any given calendar year for Papua New Guineans to repent and turn over a new leaf with enough to go around for seconds and thirds.  Much like the Parliament has 109 reasons to repent from playing marbles with people’s lives and to stop selling our country short.  Just as much as they need to repent from missing large chunks of parliamentary sittings and to actually stand up on the floor of parliament to carry out sound intellectual debates on pressing issues facing this sovereign nation.  To repent from unnecessary spending that would benefit only a few to actually putting money into where it is most needed so that our people from the urban to the most far-flung rural communities have access to basic services.

That is the type of repentance that Papua New Guinea is yearning for. Not another excuse for a holiday.

Porn makes the rounds in Kimbe   Post Courier 31.8.11

A concerned parent in West New Britain Province is disturbed by the increase in the production of local pornography which was now being circulated in the streets of Kimbe. The parent, who does not wish to be named, said he discovered a locally produced pornography movie on his son’s laptop the other day and immediately recognised the actors who he said were public servants in Kimbe. He questioned his son who was a school student about the pornographic movie and where he had got it from and was told the movie was being circulated on the streets and students had easy access to such materials. The parent said youths, especially students, were walking around with flash drives containing locally produced blue movies and claimed that there were also movies being produced by local females and Asians which involved a lot of money. “As a concerned father, I am very frustrated with this matter as our children are being exploited with these stupid things,” he said.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – July 2011

http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/editorial/when-the-chief-bows-out-20110703-1gxfq.html  accessed 4 July   Survival of the Fattest

In resource Rich developing nations the noted Oxford economist Paul Collier has observed a corrosive political culture of the ”survival of the fattest”. Democracy notwithstanding, Collier argues that a sudden rush of money into a poor economy so distorts the function of government that it is the local big men – not society as a whole – who reap the rewards. As Papua New Guinea experiences an extraordinary resource-led boom, Canberra will be hoping that Collier will be proved wrong.

How will tensions be resolved between the massive flows of foreign investment into resources, logging and development – mainly from Asia – and Australia’s persistent efforts to use our large aid program to fight corruption and to promote good governance?

PNG’s economy is expected to grow faster than China’s this year and massive new liquefied natural gas projects alone promise to push GDP up by 20 per cent. Other projects are following the resources money, like a proposed $480 million special economic zone and new city on the island of Bougainville, site of a massive copper mine closed during the secessionist conflict.

Yet despite the frenzied exploitation of its natural riches, PNG stands at 137th on the UN’s Human Development Index, at 154th on Transparency International’s corruption index and in 2008 the Auditor-General estimated corrupt officials were stealing $356 million a year in a nation with an annual GDP of just $13.4 billion. The government is concurrently facing unprecedented opportunity alongside chronic problems of inequality, crime, environmental damage and the failure of basic service delivery. There is little choice but to keep banging, and funding, the good-governance drum, because only strong institutions can ensure resource wealth is translated into stability and prosperity – not just for the fattest, but for all.

K1.9m ravaged

The National 4 July 11

A TOTAL K1.9 million of the development budget has been committed in just three months and much of it in questionable projects, an investigation reveals.
Nearly K23 million out of a K30 million, allocated under the church-state partnership programme, was reported to have disappeared leaving only K22,000 in the till as of June 1.
A total K30 million was allocated to social development funds governed by the church-state partnership framework and executed between the state and church partners in October 2008.
It was reported that between March and May this year, a total of K7,160,263.66 was released to projects without records for the balance of K22,817,321.34.
The balance as of June 1 was only K22,415.

Pupils in remote school get laptops

Post Courier, 4 July

Students of Matkomnai Primary School in the North Fly District of Western Province recently received 70 solar-powered laptops, under a “One Laptop Per Children” program initiated and sponsored by PNG Sustainable Development Program Ltd.
A ceremony was held at the school recently where Lawrence Stephens, PNGSDP’s program manager for Community and Social Investment Program (CSIP) and Coordinator of the OLPC program handed over the laptops to grades four and five pupils.
The event was witnessed by the students, parents, teachers and the community.
Other guests included Bishop Gill Cote, Catholic bishop of Daru Kiunga Diocese and district education officials.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 3 July

PNG population heads for 7 million this year

WHEN A COUNTRY has an annual population growth rate of three percent, it doubles in size every 20 years. And while PNG’s growth rate is a touch lower at 2.7 percent, the influx of migrants, especially from Asian countries, is taking it close to this benchmark.

Meanwhile, even as the country cries out for skilled labour, more and more Papua New Guineans are heading off to work overseas in what could become a debilitating ‘brain drain’ for the country. Some 20% of Papua New Guinean tertiary graduates live overseas. It’s a loss that isn’t really balanced by remittances, although the average Papua New Guinean sends home $7,232 each year.

Discussions on Pikinini Court continue

The National 5 July 11

Consultations are still being carried out between the welfare office at the Department of Community Development and relevant parties for the establishment of Pikinini Courts.
This is a requirement of the Lukautim Pikinini (Child) Act 2009, senior child protection officer Terry Lui said. Speaking at a consultative meeting for family and sexual violence committee at the Granville Motel last Wednesday, Lui told participants that talks were still being held to determine when the Pikinini Court should be established to deal specifically with children’s cases. “Court cases to do with sexual offences and other child abuses often see a child’s right to privacy and confidentiality violated and often the child is helpless or victimised when this happens,” he said. “We hope that through the Pikinini Court, we can address and protect a child’s personal integrity and maintain confidence and trust.”
Under the Act, child protection matters will be heard by the Pikinini Court and a magistrate of any other court except village court can preside where it is not possible for a magistrate of Pikinini Court to attend.
Lui said the office of Lukautim Pikinini, with the Department of Community Development, formerly known as the Child Welfare branch, had no funds to meet most of the targeted programmes under the Act.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/nation/world-health-organisation-set-to-intervene-on-closure-of-torres-strait-tuberculosis-clinics/story-e6frg6nf-1226095469339 accessed 17 July

World Health Organisation set to intervene on closure of Torres Strait tuberculosis clinics.

From: The Australian

THE World Health Organisation looks set to intervene in Australia’s decision to shut down vital Torres Strait tuberculosis clinics, which currently treat sick Papua New Guinean nationals.

The Australian Online has obtained email correspondence from WHO’s regional TB adviser, Dr Kitty Van Weezenbeek, which outlines the global health body’s concerns over Australia’s plan to transfer the patients to PNG facilities. When the clinics, run by a team of Queensland Health doctors and nurses, are forced to close in October, the patients will be treated at Daru Hospital, in PNG’s Western Province. But the hospital has difficulty accessing clean water, sanitation and medicine.

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201107/s3270032.htm accessed 17 July

PNG literacy rate in reverse – drops below 50%

Papua New Guinea’s National Reserach Institute says the country’s literacy rate has gone backwards, dropping to below 50 per cent.  The Institute wants the government to get serious about providing education and take greater action to achieve it. They say achieving basic education is critical to development.

Thomas Webster: The literacy rate in 2000 census and then updated of course with the 2011 census has been conducted this week, but the 2000 census findings estimated about 56 per cent literacy rate. Now the year before last there was a study conducted by an NGO group that looked at actual functioning literacy rate then, and they established the actual literacy rates are much, much lower than that, they estimated about 30 to 40 per cent. The reason being that the census questionnaire was based on asking people and say can you read and write in English, Tok Pisin or Motu? And if people said yes they were ticked off, if they said no, they were considered illiterate. So it was based on that question. There wasn’t any real test to measure whether they had any functional literacy rate or not. So it was the way we sort of conducted that measure that the instrument through which we monitored the literacy rate was inadequate to monitor or to capture actually whether they were functionally literate or not.

Even in the urban areas there are pockets where people are marginalised. It’s basically they’re dropping out because they don’t have the money to pay the school fees that are being charged by schools, there are other costs related to going to school like lunches, school clothes, clean clothes, textbooks, these sort of things add to the cost of school, and therefore there are many people who are marginalised who cannot afford it. They just let their kids leave (for) school.

High number of fake medical drugs in PNG

Post Courier 15 July 11

A small sampling study of anti-infective medicines in PNG has found that 100 per cent of the drugs tested failed to meet quality control or authenticity testing. The findings provide further evidence of the scale of the counterfeit and substandard drug problem in “lower income countries where product information and drug regulation enforcement are scant or absent,” according to the researchers from Goethe University in Germany.
The study examined 14 samples of an antibiotic (amoxicillin) and antimalarial (amiodaquone) bought from five registered pharmacies in Port Moresby, the country’s capital. None of the 14 samples met the testing criteria, which focused on visual inspection, quality control tests, and verification of product authenticity.
“Two products, one of which was purportedly distributed by a company which proved to be nonexistent, contained no detectable amodiaquine,” note the authors of the study, which ran on the Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences website on June 30, ahead of publication. “This quality problem with anti-infective products is of great concern, as it not only exposes patients to poor quality products but also fosters the development of resistant bacterial strains,” they conclude.

Elections 2012

The Electoral Commissioner also announced the tentative program for the 2012 General Elections. The issue of writs will be on Friday, April 27, 2012 at 4 pm. Nominations will close on Friday, May 4, 2012 and polling will start on Saturday June 23, 2012. Polling will end on Friday July 6, 2012 and the return of writs will be on or before Friday July 27, 2012. He said the program was subject to variations.

Doctors in Bougainville

There are only ten qualified doctors in the whole of Bougainville, and eight of them are in Buka.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 18 July

Ask not what your country can do for you

THE OLD GUARD in Papua New Guinean politics has had its day; it’s time for a new generation of younger, educated politicians to step up to the plate.  How often have you read or heard this sentiment? Trouble is, when you look around, there’s no one readily apparent who fits the bill or who isn’t already considerably tainted or shop worn. In this sense, it might be useful to take a look over the near horizon for a role model – towards Vanuatu perhaps.

That little chain of islands has many of the characteristics of Papua New Guinea.  Its people are Melanesian and a similarly inappropriate system of government when it gained independence. The parliament is made up of a government and opposition which are virtually indistinguishable and which spend their time doing deals and playing musical members.  Vested interests reign supreme and corruption is rife.  Sound familiar?

There is one who stands out from the crowd however.  His name is Ralph John Regenvanu. Ralph is 40 years old.  He has an honours degree from the Australian National University, where he studied anthropology, archaeology and development studies. He was director of the Vanuata Cultural Centre from 1995-2006 and director of the Vanuatu National Cultural Council from 1995 -2010.  He became a Member of Parliament in 2008.  Transparency International said he was elected by the “protest vote” – essentially people who were sick and tired of the same old politicians.

In January 2009 he announced that he would use part of his parliamentary salary to set up and finance scholarships for students undertaking foundation-level studies at the University of the South Pacific in the capital, Port Vila. In the first year 12 students received scholarships; by the second year it was 19 because he had attracted other sponsors to the scheme. In March 2009 he began to finance a Youth Solidarity Micro-Credit Scheme out of his parliamentary salary, providing loans to assist young people to set up small business projects. In 2010 he donated one-tenth of his annual salary to a campaign to clean up litter in Port Vila.  In the same year he donated money to promote youth groups. He also started a radio program where people can ring in and ask him questions or express their views.

He is not afraid to expose corruption and mismanagement in the government and the public service.  He is a critic of the constituency funds that are allocated to MPs and not monitored. This year, as Minister for Lands, he started reforming land laws so that applications for registration of customary land leases would require the consent of entire clans and not just a few greedy individuals. This upset the members of Parliament who had long been involved in shonky land deals and they forced a reshuffle and demanded control of his portfolio.

Ralph was given the Justice and Social Affairs portfolio in the reshuffle but he didn’t give up on his campaign and immediately announced that he would reform the Customary Lands Tribunal system along with a number of other legal matters that concerned him. Less than two weeks after taking over the portfolio he called for the descendants of “black birding” victims living in Australia to be given Vanuatu citizenship. One wonders and hopes that there is a similar young firebrand waiting for his chance in PNG.

Social protection idea

Post Courier 20 July 11

PROGRAMS aimed at helping people to stop them falling into poverty, helping those who are trapped in poverty and empowering people manage their lives better are now being considered. The social protection programs will enable government to help people directly in times of hardship and are distinct from traditional social services, such as education and health.
In 2009, the NEC set up a task force comprising of eight government departments to investigate and report on a formal policy model for social protection in the country. A target group was identified who were very much in need of this service. The group includes people such as the elderly and people living with disability and children. The investigation also showed two case studies of existing social protection related programs for the elderly in New Ireland and Domel in Western Highlands. Studies were also conducted in five countries in Asia-Pacific region to give further strength to this system.
There will be a high level stakeholder forum next month in Port Moresby. The forum will look at a first and second draft reports on the policy model. The report was thoroughly reviewed and critiqued by a focus group with additional inputs from technical experts. The aim of the forum is highlight the key concepts and definition of the subject which is new and should not be confused by the “dole system” or State welfare. The forum hopes to create awareness on the importance of having a national policy on social protection and its contribution to the people’s welfare and national growth.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/free-trade-not-what-pacific-needs accessed 21 July

Free trade is not what the Pacific needs

The article below by Nick Dearden argues that African prosperity relies on a wholesale rejection of the western free trade model, which is still being promoted by the USA, Europe and their economic allies like Australia.

Papua New Guinea has recently approved a new Interim Economic Partnership Agreement with the European Union and is being pressured by Australia and New Zealand to sign the  Pacific Agreement on Closer Economic Relations (PACER).

But, just like Africa, PNG should be looking to follow its own development path and reject the plundering of its resources by foreign interests aided by naive and greedy politicians and bureaucrats. The free-trade agenda of the west is part of their failed neo-liberal economic model and does not match PNG’s own Constitution and National Goals.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/more-questions-answers-pmiz-coc-meeting accessed 14 July

More questions than answers on PMIZ at CoC meeting

The latest meeting of the Madang Chamber of Commerce has thrown up more questions than answers about the government’s controversial Pacific Marine Industrial Zone, as this report by Nancy Sullivan reveals: Stotick Kamya [President of the Chamber of Commerce and ex RD manager] gave us a cheerful progress report on the PMIZ and its scope of work. Included in it was an admission that money had run out last year for both the environmental and social impact assessments, which have still been left unpaid, and that all the settlers within the fenced area have been paid off but they are now asking for more (the tone implying how greedy they must be).

Some kerfuffle ensued when he suggested by misstatement that ALL Rempi people were settlers, which got the hairs up on one CoC members back (who also queried the rumour that the PMIZ is to have private access banning landowners to waters offshore to 500 metres out from Rempi to Alexishafen – Stotick was unsure).

The presentation went on to include a discussion of the Gold Coast of PNG, a spectacular new development planned for up the north coast road, clearly piggybacking the town joy of a Pacific Marine Industrial Zone,  sponsored by Coral Seas and other private entities (land clearing has already begin!) – where we can expect luxury villas, swimming pools, golf courses and malls.

It would seem that evicting landowners from these marvellous new retirement and industrial zones has not been a problem…

Blind children missing out

Post Courier 14 July 11

ALMOST 160,000 vision impaired children who need specialist attention in PNG are not receiving adequate education, according to a research. This was revealed on Tuesday during a three-day inaugural national universal basic education (UBE) conference at the National Research Institute (NRI) in Port Moresby.
A research fellow and a PhD candidate at the James Cook University in Townsville, Australia, James Aiwa said it was clear that many children who needed specialist VI services were not receiving them.
“Preliminary results indicated that majority of about 366 students who received specialist services in 2009 used braille and legally blind students with low vision, students who are able to see things within three metre being seriously neglected,” he said.
Mr Aiwa said the teachers in the survey identified significant problems including the negative attitudes of parents, regular teachers having over focus on disability rather than students’ abilities, the need for specialist pre-service and in-service training and lack of resources to support student transition to secondary and tertiary education.
The three recommendations he made were a firm commitment to achieve equity and access for all children including those with VI by 2015; identify all children with VI; and ensure that they are all assessed and appropriately supported and provide relevant pre- and in-service training and material resources.

‘PNG fails to implement development’

Post Courier 12 July 11

PAPUA New Guinea is very good in “planning for development” but has completely failed to actually implement development,” said New Ireland Governor Sir Julius Chan. Mr Chan was speaking during the opening of the Consultative Implementation Monitoring Council NGI Regional Forum in Kavieng last week Thursday. “We have an alphabet soup of agencies and committees and councils all devoted to either planning for development or monitoring how we are planning for development or to changing how we do development because the way we have been doing development has not been working,” he said.
He said “but when it came to implementing development, PNG has completely failed”.
The Governor made mention of the Medium Term Development Strategy for 1997 – 2002, the MTDS for 2005 – 2010 and the MTDS 2011- 2015, which he said were all the same. He quoted some of the goals including using the revenues from mining, petroleum and gas to improve the social and economic conditions of the people as well as reducing the level of poverty in Papua New Guinea and ensure that no Papua New Guineans are being left behind. “We are saying the same things in 2011 that we said in 1997? Why is this? Very simply, it is because we have not done what we promised we would do,” he said.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/local-communities-file-complaint-ifc-over-pmiz-and-sez-laws accessed 12 July

Local communities file complaint with IFC over PMIZ and SEZ laws

Local communities affected by the proposed Pacific Marine Industrial Zone in Madang have filed a formal complaint in Washington about the role of the International Finance Corporation in promoting the project and in developing Special Economic Zone laws in PNG. The communities have filed their complaint with the International Finance Corporation Ombudsman. The IFC is a part of the World Bank Group which is based in the United States. The complaint, which has been formally endorsed by over 100 landholders and is supported by many more, alleges there has never been any proper consultation with landholders about the PMIZ and they have never given their free, informed consent to the project. The landholders also say they have already suffered enough from the environmental damage, foul smells and social problems caused by the existing RD Tuna factory and do not want more tuna canneries on their land. The compliant also says the IFC has been involved in drafting legislation to allow tax free Special Economic Zones in PNG which are not in the interests of the majority of people and will not improve their social conditions.

Madang yet to effect 476 arrests

The National 12 July 11

THERE are 476 outstanding bench warrants in Madang – the oldest issued by the court in 1987, according to the national court listing. And police have blamed the lack of resources and manpower for the problem. According to the listing, the 476 bench warrant matters remain outstanding after the last week’s court circuit visit by Justice John Kawi. When asked to explain the backlog, police station commander Steven Kaipa said many of the offenders were from outside the province. And those in the province lived in remote areas, he said. The situation in Madang was compounded by the fact that most of the police vehicles needed urgent repairs or were beyond repair.

From pp 133 ff of the PNG Medium Term Development Plan 2011-215

6.1 Economic Corridors

Economic Corridors are proposed to alleviate poverty. Corridors of poverty will be transformed into Economic corridors. Without the corridor system people in poverty will not be integrated into the mainstream economy. An Economic Corridor is a region in which the Government provides a well planned zoning system, a comprehensive and effective network of transport and utilities, quality education, and health services. Within this region, businesses are able to operate at low cost and under well designed incentives, thereby encouraging foreign and domestic private sector investment. By concentrating the construction of essential infrastructure within certain regions, the Economic Corridor approach takes advantage of the substantial economies of scale and scope associated with large service sector infrastructure. This reduces the cost to state owned enterprises and other providers of essential infrastructure, while raising their returns. Building on this infrastructure, effective sequential and spatial planning will help to expand economic activities like agriculture, tourism and manufacturing.

MTDP 2011-2015

The Government has identified ten regions of PNG to be categorised as Economic Corridors. Within the next five years, efforts will be focused on developing four economic corridors. These are as follows.

Petroleum Resource Area Economic Corridor (PRAEC) (Southern Highlands, parts of Enga, Gulf and Central Provinces). The PRAEC was approved by Cabinet in May 2009.

· Central Corridor (Central, Milne Bay, Oro and Morobe).

· South Coast Corridor (East New Britain and West New Britain).

· Momase Corridor (Madang, East Sepik, and West Sepik).

Development of these corridors will be coordinated by Economic Corridor Implementation Authorities (ECIAs). Legislation will set out the powers, functions and responsibilities of an ECIA in mobilising, planning and managing development in the Economic Corridor. Until the ECIAs are well established as a separate entity, they will operate under the Department of National Planning and Monitoring. Over the next five years, implementation of the Economic Corridors and establishment of the ECIAs will be sequenced through a number of phases. During the first phase, policy, legislation, ECIA governance and reporting mechanisms will be in place to support a fully functional ECIA. The first ECIA will be the PRAEC ECIA. The second phase will produce targeted sectoral studies with geographical overlay. An integrated development strategy and plan will be developed during phase three, alongside a proposal of specific projects and programs to be implemented within each corridor, in line with government priorities identified in MTDP 2011-2015 and PNGDSP. Phase four will focus on the implementation and monitoring of selected projects and programs. ECIAs will work closely with provincial, district and town authorities to harmonise development initiatives, coordinating efforts in order to bring about greater results in the corridors. ECIAs will only initiate flagship projects of national interest in their various corridors, specifically in economic infrastructure (transportation, energy and telecommunication), social infrastructure (health, education, and research and development), and projects for economic pursuit (agriculture, fisheries, forestry, downstream processing, and small-medium enterprise development). ECIAs will not implement development initiatives at provincial and local levels, rather this will be the responsibility of provincial and lower level authorities.

6.2.4 Churches

Goal: Effective health, education and community service delivery through a close and sustainable partnership with PNG’s churches

Churches have contributed to the development of PNG for over 100 years and continue to play an important role in nation building by fostering spiritual, social and economic growth. The Government has recognised the efforts of churches in partnering with the Government to provide basic social services such as health and education under difficult circumstances in many parts of the country, especially in the rural areas where the majority of the population lives, but where government services are either inadequate or lacking. Over the next five years the Government will continue to support PNG’s churches through the Church-State Partnership. At least K60 million will be directed by the Government through PNG’s churches to help deliver health and education services. Within the period 2011-2015, it is the Government’s commitment to ensure that a close working relationship is maintained with PNG’s churches through establishing joint coordination meetings, establishing independent monitoring mechanisms to assess performances, and continuing to maintain and strengthen development partnerships.

Fight against domestic violence

Post Courier 22 July 11

ONE of the main tasks of the Lihir Tutorme Women’s Association is to help in efforts to curb domestic violence that is affecting people on Lihir Island by contributing in whatever way it can, to alleviate these problems. Tutorme means “Stand together” in the local Lihir lauguage.
Domestic violence workshops conducted by the community policing unit are a motivating factor to the association to participate by working together with participants of these workshops to fight these problems. Mrs Lusem said in the past, the association was fully aware of these problems because they were affecting their people on a daily basis, but they did not know who to work with to clamp down on it.
Mrs Lusem said their visits around Lihir confirm that the Island is experiencing a marked increase in domestic violence related problems with mothers and children being abused and sexual harassment is rife. She expressed concern that Lihir is feeling the effects of these problems and assured the participants that the association will work with them to put into practice what they learn at the domestic violence workshops.

The challenges in banking

The National 22 July 11, editorial

BANKS, which ought to be the most welcome places to be at, are today the most forbidding.
The queues snake their way right outside bank doors on most days. The wait is interminable.
When, with tempers already frayed, a customer finally hauls herself before the counter, often she is put through a gruelling questioning by the teller that is closer to police interrogation.
Quite often, the question pops up, in silent contemplation or in angry retort: “Does this bank want my business?
“Why are you treating me with contempt – is it because my deposits are smaller than big businesses?
Why are you making it difficult to access my own mo­ney?”
Then, there are the horrendous fees charged and we cannot help it but get the feeling that that customers do get charged for the hard time they have with the bank. Each transaction is charged.
It drives one to want to keep his or her money in a tin in a hole in the backyard.  It has become so that saving, which is a chore for the average Papua New Guinean, is now virtually impossible.

Water to settlers shut due to wastage  

The National 29 July 11

A NUMBER of settlements in Port Moresby have been without water since last month after Eda Ranu clamped down on illegal connections and unpaid water bills by disconnecting supply to the area. Parts of Morata, Wild Life and 8-Mile settlements have faced intermittent water supply, or none at all, since June.
Eda Ranu says, “There are many illegal settlements springing up all over the place.  “We are not denying anyone water, but because Morata is a non-paying area, we need to control flow and pressure to reduce wastage, and reduce our operational costs of treatment and maintenance.” Visits by Eda Ranu workers to these areas have noted open taps running 24-hour a day, thus forcing it to put in place measures to control water usage. Currently there are 31 settlements, both legal and illegal, receiving water from Eda Ranu.However, only two – Oro ATS and Morobe Block – are paying.
“Despite our findings, we continue to supply water to these communities.”
Meanwhile NCDC chief health surveyor Robin Yanepa, in a letter to Eda Ranu’s operations manager dated July 19, said after investigating the case: “There is already evidence of skin disease infections and likely possibility of an outbreak of disease, including cholera”.
“From the stream water samples collected and tested, it shows that the water is highly contaminated with faecal bacteria”.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/over-2-million-be-affected-upcoming-drought-papua-new-guinea accessed 31 July

Over 2 million to be affected by upcoming drought in PNG

More than 2 million people in Papua New Guinea stand to be affected by severe food and water shortages unless serious steps are taken to ease the effects of a possible drought in the next 12 months.

The warning came from Papua New Guinea’s National Agriculture Research Institute (NARI) which says there has to be a collective effort by government agencies as well as communities to deal with the effects.  NARI’s warning comes in light of increasing global attention on the plight of coastal communities impacted by global warming and climate change.  While much of the focus is on coastal areas, the institute is reporting an increase in crop diseases and poor harvests as a result of higher temperatures in highland areas.

Current data from various international agencies show that drier and hotter periods  are becoming frequent and more intensive.  While a  nationwide drought is a long term possibility, people can expected to see intermittent localized droughts. The impacts of expected long dry periods won’t just affect food security.  With about  90 percent of Papua New Guinea’s electricity needs supplied by hydroelectric dams,  droughts will result in power rationing and increased costs to businesses and individuals. “Drought is everybody’s problem,” says Dr. Ramakrishna. “We can’t just wait on the government to address it.” In the face of  funding problems, the institute continues to push the government to consider the establishment of food banks, resilient agriculture systems and better water security.

More dialogue needed for (sex) laws

Post Courier 29 July 11

Calling on Churches and civil society groups to be very honest in their opinions, the country’s Attorney General and Justice Minister Sir Arnold Amet said yesterday that dialogue would continue on sex laws.
He said the government cannot make any changes until and unless it is satisfied that these changes are for the good of society. Changes to the sex laws have been mooted by the Department of Community Development, however, most church clergymen yesterday voiced severe opposition, saying any change would increase the suffering of men and women.
Sir Arnold said he personally does not support prostitution or homosexual behaviour, and the government would have to study all aspects and hear all sides before it makes a decision on any proposed changes.
He said that the terms of reference on the review are before his department for consultation.
The consultation also heard that the debate on discriminating sex laws relating to prostitution and homosexuality is based on human rights merit and especially the HIV/ AIDS management.
Fr John Glynn of WeCARE, while strongly opposing the review on sex laws, said it was men who wanted this law and equates it to slavery and sex industry will become a thriving industry if these laws are reviewed. Archbishop of Port Moresby, John Ribat also supported Fr Glynn, adding that sex industry will only get out of hand, it will grow wild, without control and it will be interpreted differently by the people.
He said it was men who push agendas around and women get to be victimised and suffer more. He questioned the great influx of people into cities while noting that one reason is there were no services back at home and people came into cities then turn to illegal means getting money. Sir Amet said these issues needed to be seriously discussed before ‘the watch is on us’. Despite this, not many church leaders attended. The Minister plans for a bigger forum in the near future with wider consultation from churches and legal minds.

K700m plan for islanders’ resettlement

The National 25 July 11

THE Madang executive council last Thursday endorsed a K700 million assistance package to be sought from the national government for the relocation of displaced Manam islanders.
This is after several years of waiting for development at the political level in terms of peace-seeking resolutions with mainlanders for resettlement. Provincial administrator Ben Lange during a press conference last week said the promised K10 million funding by the government early this year was yet to be received for groundwork to be done.
He said the K700 million would be used in phases over the next five years, with the first phase to begin in September.
The break-up of the K700 includes: K10 million for feasibility studies; K450 million for survey, building and construction by next year; K50 million for resettlement of displaced islanders and rehabilitation; K180 million to be paid as compensation to the Andarum villagers, whose land will be acquired for the resettlement; and K10 million for monitoring, coordination and evaluation. Lange said the aim of the exercise was to settle all the displaced Manam islanders living in the care centres by 2015.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 25 July

Govt resigns to improve malaria fight

AS PAPUA NEW GUINEA continues its battle to contain and prevent malaria, officials say the government’s decision to resign as the principal recipient of monies from the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis and Malaria, will improve its response. “Stepping down as a principal recipient was a difficult decision to make,” said Leo Sora Makita, principal technical adviser for malaria and vector-borne disease for the Department of Health. “We actually had to step down because we need a principal recipient that can effectively manage the funds and report back to Global Fund.” The decision followed a Global Fund audit in September and October 2010, when it found the Department of Health had not complied with grant guidelines and some $7 million had been misdirected.

Makita agreed there were some weaknesses in the system and the funds were not managed effectively. Since April, when the Department of Health announced it would no longer shoulder the management of the $50 million in Global Fund grants, discussions on how to keep the money flowing to this South Pacific island nation have taken place behind closed doors with the Global Fund’s country coordinating mechanism. Oil Search, one of PNG’s biggest and oldest companies, was appointed the new principal recipient at end-June. In addition to producing oil and gas in PNG, Oil Search has run several successful anti-malarial programs since the 1990s and says it has an expertise that can be tapped for its new role. “When the Department of Health was looking at pulling out of managing the money, we put our hand up to take on the responsibility,” Peter Botten, managing director of Oil Search, said. Botten said he foresees a more predictable and effective delivery on the Global Fund grant goals with Oil Search at the helm of money management, but working in conjunction with the Department of Health.

With 90% of the nation’s six million people at risk of contracting malaria, combined with a growing resistance to Chloroquine, the first line of treatment, the government of PNG considers malaria among the country’s top five health issues. The country achieved a 26% decrease in malaria cases from 2004-09, from 1.9 million reported cases in 2004 to 1.4 million in 2009, according to the World Health Organisation. But such a reduction does not constitute a success story just yet, said Zaixing Zhang, malarial scientist with WHO in Port Moresby.

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 26 July

Ramu mine waste dumping: Injunction refused

LIVE FROM MADANG:   Justice Canning sitting in the National Court in Madang has refused an application by indigenous landholders for a permanent injunction preventing the marine dumping of toxic waste from the Ramu nickel mine.

The judge said that although the landholders did have standing, had established that there was a serious likelihood of irreversible harm that would constitute both a public and private nuisance and that the dumping would breach the National Goals and Directive Principles in Papua New Guinea’s Constitution, he was refusing the application for a permanent injunction.

Justice Canning gave as his reasons for refusing the plaintiff’s application their delay in bringing a court action, the fact the marine dumping has been approved by the government and the economic consequences for the mining company and investor confidence if the marine dumping was stopped.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – June 2011

Social Concern Notes – June 2011

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201106/s3254119.htm accessed 27 June

Fee for Refugees wanting citizenship

In Papua New Guinea, there have been calls for the National Government to lower its fees for refugees wanting citizenship. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees wants the cost of citizenship to be dropped, to help West Papuan refugees already living in the country to obtain citizenship.
The fee for citizenship is a huge 10-thousand kina or four thousand-400 dollars.

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201106/s3242984.htm accessed 15 June

New Chinese-built urban centre for Bougainville

Chinese investors have presented details of a plan to build a major new urban centre on Papua New Guinea’s Island of Bougainville. The multi-millon dollar development would be built on government-owned land and would be declared a Special Economic Zone.

http://pngexposed.wordpress.com/ accessed 14 June

National Alliance plans to turn Madang Province into Philippines style industrial zone

Papua New Guinea’s ruling National Alliance party wants to make the Province of Madang into a Philippines style industrial zone using a combination of corporate tax exemptions and Chinese investment and labour.

The plan, which is championed by the Attorney General, and ex Madang governor, Arnold Amet, and current governor James Gau, was the focus of a recent trip to the Philippine’s by a delegation of bureaucrats and local leaders to the Subic Bay Freeport, established in 1992.

The National Alliance plan will see Madang become the mining capital of PNG with both the huge Ramu nickel and Yandera gold and copper mines pumping their toxic tailings in to the sea. Both mines are being developed by Chinese companies..

In addition the government wants to see up to 10 tuna canneries operating as part of the Pacific Marine Industrial Zone. The PMIZ is to be built by another Chinese company using funds loaned to PNG by the Chinese Export-Import bank.

The PMIZ will be designated by the government as a Special Economic Zone which means it will offer generous tax exemptions to foreign companies and operate as a fenced enclosure with private security to prevent unauthorized access. With the Zone normal migration, labour, health and safety and environmental laws will not apply.

The National 14 June: Hundreds walk to fight graft

THE courage to blow the whistle is the key to weeding out corruption, Rev Samson Lowa, who led the Transparency International PNG “Walk Against Corruption” on Sunday in Port Moresby, says.
Speaking at the Jack Pidik Park at 5-Mile, Lowa said corruption “is rampant in PNG and it has to be rooted out from within the hearts and minds of individual Papua New Guineans”.
“There are Papua New Guineans who want to blow the whistle on corruption but lack the courage. “Fighting corruption is everyone’s business,” he said.
Referring to placards carried by anti-corruption groups, Lowa said: “The message is clear now that people of all walks of life hate corruption and they want to root it out through any means.”
More than 2,400 anti-corruption campaigners walked the streets of Port Moresby.
The common slogans on placards were “vote out corruption, don’t support it; report it”.

http://www.islandsbusiness.com/islands_business/index_dynamic/containerNameToReplace=MiddleMiddle/focusModuleID=19708/overideSkinName=issueArticle-full.tpl accessed 15 June

Court challenge for Madang PMIZ

Local landowners oppose $m project
PNG’s Pacific Marine Industrial Zone (PMIZ) project that is being planned for development in partnership with other Pacific Islands countries is being challenged in court.
The local people are concerned at what they claim is a lack of transparency in the way the project is being developed, which has not really involved and benefitted them. The court challenge follows two forums held by the plaintiffs this year to air their grievances about the project.
The government says the PMIZ will incorporate up to 10 tuna processing factories that will employ 30,000 people. The PNG government has named a relatively unknown Chinese investor to be the major developer of the Pacific Marine Industrial Zone project. The company, which calls itself Shenyang International Economic and Technical Cooperation Co. Ltd, employs up to 100 people and is expected to develop the US$300 million Pacific Marine Industrial Zone project.
The PMIZ project will be funded by a K202 million (US$71 million) concessional loan from Exim Bank of China.
The main condition for the loan is that 70 percent of the project must go exclusively to a Chinese developer using Chinese technology, labour and equipment. Other PNG firms can only bid for the remaining 30 percent of the contract if it becomes available. Another condition tied to the loan is that the main contractor’s profit margin will be 20 percent of the contract value.
Minister Kapris said the reason why the government decided to go to the Chinese was because it would be quicker to get the loan. He said since this was a concessional loan, the main contractor and supplier would be from the sponsoring nation, while the sub-contracts for the project would be from PNG.

PC 16 June 11: PNG not prepared for sex laws
DECRIMINALISING sex laws is something PNG is not ready for but the legislative package is with the Law Reform Commission to consider. The Minister for Community Development, Dame Carol Kidu, said this yesterday while summing up the issues that were highlighted on Tuesday during the national dialogue on HIV, Human Rights and Law.
She said the Government has not been giving a “go ahead” for changes when the bill was proposed, and it has been referred to the Law Reform Commission.
Dame Carol said the decriminalisation of sex laws was not trying to be in conflict with the churches but protect the rights of key affected groups of people including women, young girls, sex workers, men who are having sex with men (MSM) and transgender.
She said this would deter the unconsensual sex within marriage and also outside which both parties would exercise their human rights.
The Minister said by this they were not trying to legalise prostitution in the country but trying to empower women, girls and other key affected people to exercise their rights.

The National 17 June 11: Bishops say funds abused

LOCAL Catholic bishops have renewed  a call for parliament to “cease the inefficient system of allocating development funds to MPs to distribute”. This was agreed to at the Ca­tholic Bishops Conference of Pa­pua New Guinea and Solomon Islands.
“This system is a direct cause of election-related violence,” the bi­shops said.
“It is open to much abuse and the potential for corruption, especially by diverting these funds to projects or even directly as cash handouts to supporters”.
“As the 2012 election approaches, we see early signs of these very abuses and fear that a great deal of the wealth of the nation will be wasted in electioneering rather than being used for real prioritised and sustainable development.”
The bishops appealed to MPs to live up to their noble calling in pla­cing the needs of the people above theirs and to use funds exclusively for the benefit of the people. “We note that famous slush funds or funds made available to a member of parliament for distribution at their discretion detracts from the dignity of the office of an MP and prevents the fulfilment of authentic political service.

The National 17 June : Paper on disabled signed

PNG  has signed the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disability (CRPD) but has yet to ra­tify it. Ratification will pave the way for the implementation process of the rights of people with disabilities in the country, key people involved in disability programmes said..
PNG ambassador to the United Nations Robert Aisi signed the convention on behalf of the go­vernment with the official ceremony published on the UN website.
The K8 million Australian government funding for the CRDP will be drawn down after the CRPD is signed.

Post Courier 17th June: Zibe: Our health worst in the region
MINISTER for Health Sasa Zibe confirmed in Parliament yesterday when making his ministerial statement that the health status of the country was the worst in the Pacific region.
Mr Zibe said over the past years, the country has seen its public hospitals and health centres slowly falling apart due to normal wear and tear and in many cases neglect by consecutive governments to provide funding for the routine maintenance and upkeep of facilities.
He said population growth and demand for health services are consistently outstripping the manpower and the facilities the country has and “we are acutely facing shortage of drugs or even when it reaches a point it is either outdated or missing”.
“We must be informed that the present system of health service delivery is fragmented and one of the reasons is that; provincial health services are delivered under a complex legal structure and this has caused difficulty,” he said.
http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 20 June

Mining boom promises unprecedented riches for who?

Many commentators are talking excitedly about the unprecedented riches that will come from Papua New Guinea’s resource boom. But who is REALLY going to reap the benefits from Papua New Guinea’s oil, gas, gold and silver?

Papua New Guinea has already experienced 20 years of massive resource exploitation. Its forests are being logged out, tuna stocks over exploited, mines like Misima are already exhausted, Ok Tedi will soon close, Porgera, Tolokuma and Lihir have been operating for more than a decade and have been joined by Sinivit, Kainantu and Simberi. But who has benefited from all these riches?

PNG ranks a lowly 137th out of 169 countries on the United Nations Human Development Index which ranks countries according to a broad measure of well being that is far more relevant to ordinary people than the usual indicators used by the exploiters, economic growth and annual income.

Papua New Guinea’s mining boom promises unprecedented riches for multinational corporations and a local elite of politicians, businessmen and bureaucrats but offers only more environmental damage and social problems caused by alcohol, violence and the break-down of family and community ties for ordinary people.

Example of Nauru (http://malumnalu.blogspot.com/ accessed 20 June)

Preserving wealth in Papua New Guinea

The proposal to set up a ‘sovereign wealth fund’ for PNG has a familiar ring to it.

The Republic of Nauru was declared in 1968. The Island’s economy was based on the extraction and export of phosphate rock, a left over from when the island was uninhabited and a roosting/nesting place for Pacific birds. In the 1960’s and 70’s, the island’s population of less than 10,000 enjoyed the highest per capita income in the South Pacific from phosphate royalties.

So what happened to Nauru’s wealth? Why has the average income of this nation’s citizens now diminished from a comfortable living to that of virtual poverty? When the phosphate reserves were exhausted, and the environment had been seriously harmed by mining, the trust that had been established to manage the island’s wealth diminished in value. To earn income, Nauru briefly became a tax haven and illegal money laundering centre. From 2001 to 2008, it accepted aid from the Australian government in exchange for housing a Nauru detention centre that held and processed those who had tried to enter Australia irregularly. Mining has also affected the surrounding Exclusive Economic Zone, with 40% of marine life estimated to have been killed by silt and phosphate runoff.

Following decades of mismanagement, corruption, and spiralling loans to General Electric, estimated to amount to approximately A$227 million, the Nauru Phosphate Royalties Trust (NPRT) was forced to sell off its international assets to pay loans. When the new Australian Labor government decided to close the Nauru detention centre in 2008, the country’s Foreign Affairs Minister Dr. Kieren Keke, stated that it would result in 100 Nauruans losing their jobs

http://pngexposed.wordpress.com/ accessed 23 June

K22 million judgement puts spotlight on GG’s role in illegal logging in Papua New Guinea

This week’s decision in the National Court, that logging company Concord Pacific pay a record K22.6 million in damages for environmental destruction caused by illegal logging, puts the spotlight on the role of Papua New Guinea’s Governor General in facilitating and supporting illegal logging and the misery it causes to the lives of ordinary people

As Forest Minister, Ogio not only approved the unlawful issuing of an extension to the Kiunga-Aiambak Timber Authority held by Concord Pacific, against the advice of five different government departments. Ogio also gave Concord Pacific three separate unlawful tax exemptions.

In handing down the courts decision on damages on Tuesday, Justice Cathy Davani was very critical of the destruction caused by the logging company. She said the destruction had completely destroyed the lives of local people, especially children and women, and the damage done was immeasurable. These impacts were the direct consequences of the unlawful actions of the Governor General and a whole line of other politicians and senior public servants.

In December 2000, Ogio granted an illegal Timber Authority for Stage 3 of the Aiambak Kiunga project. This was illegal as the Minister had no power to grant a Timber Authority and no proper application or allocation procedures had been followed. This was later pointed out to the Minister in a letter from the National Forest Board – a letter which he ignored.

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201106/s3253004.htm accessed 25 June

Thousands suffer food shortage on Bougainville atolls

Over 12 thousand people from the atoll islands in Papua New Guinea’s Autonomous Region of Bougainville are facing food shortages and need urgent help.
Their MP, Lauta Atoi told the PNG parliament that people now cannot grow food on the atolls because of sea level rise and a prolonged drought.
He says there’s no long term food security for the atoll islanders.
The National 24 June 11: Mines ready for huge production

PAPUA New Guinea’s mining industry is poised to produce 31,325,500oz of gold and silver and 165,000 tonnes of copper this year.
Officer-in-charge of the Mineral Resources Authority (MRA) Philip Samar told a mines and money conference in Beijing last week that these production figures were expected from the six mines operating in the country at present.
The mines are Porgera, Ok Tedi, Tolukuma, Sinivit, Simberi and Newcrest (Lihir).
Out of the production figures and commodities, Porgera is expected to produce 500,000oz of gold and 80,000oz of silver, Ok Tedi 400,000oz of gold, 1,000,000oz of silver and 165,000 tonnes of copper, Tolukuma 70,000oz of gold and 150,000oz of silver, Sinivit 50,000oz of gold and 2,500oz of silver, Simberi 800,000oz of gold, while Lihir is expected to produce 800,000oz of gold.
Samar said PNG had four major mines in advanced stages of construction which were expected to come on stream in the near future.
The mines are Ramu NiCo (more than 30 years life span), Solwara-1 (five years), Yandera (10 years) and Frieda projects with expected mine life of 20 years.

Ok Tedi mine suspends community projects worth over K150m

Ok Tedi mine has given notice to stakeholders of the suspension and termination of tax credit projects in Western and Sundaun Provinces worth over K150 million. The miner says the decision is a direct result of the ‘significant losses’ to mine income caused by the prolonged suspension of mining operations due to a tailings pipeline failure.

The decision to suspend or terminate projects affects the following ongoing projects:

Project Value
Balimo Hospital Project K39,319,360.62
Fly River Jetties Upgrading Program K14,000,000.00
Olsobip Airstrip upgrading K2,460,000.00
Kiunga Town Sewerage system upgrade K18,000,000.00
Kiunga town water supply system upgrade K18,600,000.00
Kiunga easipay project K1,332,000.00
Kiunga New Sub Divisions Stages 1,2,3&4 K27,322,223.80
Okaspmin High School -Tekin K25,920,000.00
Telefomin High School Maintenance and Upgrade K9,500,000.00
Telefomin Inspectors H65 Kit Houses. K300,000.00
Wangbin Community School K3,092,059.00
Wipim School Inspector’s House K800,000.00

Other proposed projects under design and investigation that have been halted are:

  • Kiunga Airport Terminal Building
  • Okma Community School
  • Korkit aidpost and APO house
  • Kwiloknai Primary School
  • Wangbin Elementary School
  • Tabubil High School and Elementary School
  • Biangabip airstrip
  • Ningerum Elementary School
  • OK Tarim Airstrip
  • Bolivip Primary school and water supply
  • Wogam Primary school
  • Montfort primary Kiunga
  • Tarakbits water and power
  • Rumginae Primary Admin office and library

http://pngexposed.wordpress.com/ accessed 27 June

Finance Inquiry findings back before the courts

Lawyer Paul Paraka and ex Solicitor General Zacchary Gelu were back in court Friday trying to ensure the Finance Department Commission of Inquiry report, which heavily implicates both men in massive corruption and fraud, remains under wraps.

The findings of the Commission of Inquiry, which were handed to the Prime Minister in December 2009, have not been officially published and the people, including Paraka and Gelu, implicated in the theft of K780 million, have not been arrested or charged because the two men have a court injunction preventing publication or any criminal action against them. The injunction was granted by Justice Sakora in March 2010

Post Courier 9 June: Families refuse to vacate PMIZ

The 156 families at Vidar plantation in Madang, where the current Pacific Marine Industrial Zone (PMIZ) project is located, have refused eviction until the National Government compensates them fully.The families, all settlers from all parts of the country currently residing at portion 1350 at the plantation at Nukuru and Maus Damon Compounds, are workers employed by RD Fishing, RD Cannery and RD Plantation.
Spokesman of the settlers Peter Rigens said that the Government, especially the Department of Commerce and Industry, must honour its promise in the Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) signed on May 2, 2011 with the displaced settlers and compensate them fully.
Mr Rigens said that on the day the MOA was signed, the settlers were paid for their garden crops which included mature bananas, taro, kaukau mounds, asparagus, betelnuts, mangoes and other economic crops. However, he said that the method of payment involved was ‘fishy’, citing that the settlers were issued with cash in white envelopes. He claimed that many settlers were disappointed to find that the amount of cash in the envelopes were less than what was written on the envelopes.
He also queried such cash payment, citing that the Government always paid people in cheques and not cash and asked Francis Irara, who coordinates the PMIZ office in Madang and the Department of Commerce and Industry to explain such method of payment.
He also said that at the time of payment, the settlers asked Mr Irara and the Department of Commerce and Industry to produce the list and number of crops on gardens for each family to be presented so payments would be done accordingly but this was not done, claiming that Mr Irara said ‘the list was left at home’.

Post Courier 9 June, feature: Girls’ school gets a boost

STEPHANIE COPUS-CAMPBELL – Head of AusAID in PNG

Papua New Guinea and Australia are supporting secondary education in the Highlands with a K5.1 million expansion at the Notre Dame Secondary School in Mt Hagen. Notre Dame is one of only four all-girls schools in Papua New Guinea and the only girls school in the Highlands region.
“With the expansion of universal basic education and more students now enrolled in primary schools across PNG, there is a great need to provide quality secondary schooling,” said Principal of Notre Dame Secondary School, Sister Mary Vivette Baker. “In Western Highlands’ secondary schools, less than 40 percent of school enrolments are girls, so this expansion will help us do our part to balance that better.
The project, funded through the PNG-Australia Incentive Fund, will include a 52 bed student dormitory, four new classrooms, a new kitchen, extended dining hall and upgraded water reticulation system. Teachers will also be supported with accommodation for a further six staff.
“This project will ultimately lead to a better learning environment and quality of education for girls in PNG,” said Head of AusAID in PNG, Stephanie Copus-Campbell.
Since upgrading the school to Secondary status the number of Notre Dame students enrolling in tertiary studies has increased from 60 to 75 percent, overall academic performance has improved and there has been less teacher turnover.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 10 June

Official shame: Trouble on the Western front

THERE IS A potential humanitarian crisis about to unfold in the Western Province of Papua New Guinea as Australia moves to prevent border crossers from accessing healthcare in the Torres Strait.

The people of South Fly in the Western Province have had access to health services on Saibai Island in Australia, for decades. Many cross the border under the Torres Strait Treaty that exists between PNG and Australia.

With the deterioration and decay of the town of Daru and its hospital, many people prefer to cross the border to seek better treatment. Patients travel to Mabuduan Health Center at the mouth of the Pahoturi River where they receive their referral letters to travel to Saibai.

Queensland Health has been faced with bearing the cost of providing this care. In recent times, the burden of treating tuberculosis has led to moves to stop providing care.

The prevention of villagers from accessing lifesaving treatment would have tragic consequences. For many who live along the coastline of the Torres Strait, getting to Saibai is much more convenient than having to travel to Daru.

People who live inland in the TransFly Savannah also find it easier to travel by foot to the Pahoturi River villages and then by canoe to Mabuduan.

The Health Centers inland at Morehead, Upiara and Wipim have chronic shortages in medical supplies. Access to these health facilities is by foot.

Axing TB clinics hurts PNG & Australia

THERE IS NO HEALTH inequality worldwide greater than Australia’s northern maritime border with Papua New Guinea.

Ranked number two on the UNDP’s Human Development Index, Australian soil is just three kilometres by sea from PNG; ranked at 137.

With tuberculosis being the most expensive single health issue to treat in the region, recent shifts in government policy risk aggravating the situation on both sides of the border.

There is an estimated 2% tuberculosis prevalence in PNG with around 50,000 annual visits to the Torres Strait islands by PNG nationals.

Post Courier 10 June: Call to erect mental care centres   

CALLS have been made by police in Madang to health authorities to consider establishing regional facilities in the country for mental health patients.
The calls are from Madang Provincial Police Commander Superintendant Anthony Wagambie (Jnr) and have been made in light of the increased complaints he has received from members of the public who have been victimized by these people.
Supt Wagambie said while some of these patients were harmless, there were others who were proving to be very aggressive and needed to be locked away.
He said this was because they were simply becoming not only a danger to the public but to themselves. He said while police had been arresting them, they could not keep them locked away in the cells given their mental state.
“…at the moment there is only one established Mental facility and that is the one at Laloki but with the increased number of patients, thoughts should be given to establishing similar set ups in the regions.
“This is because we cannot allow these people to roam the streets,” he said.

Post Courier 10 June: Marape clears air on fees   

The initial belief that Government would pay 50 per cent for first six months of school fees for students attending primary schools next year as stated in The National on May 27 has been changed to a time frame of four years.
Education Minister James Marape clarified the report by stating that much consideration had been made over the impact this would cause to the budget had it been given the go ahead.
He said the National Alliance Party had a policy on paying for education for elementary and primary students to help with the implementation of the Universal Basic Education (UBE).
He explained the policy was in line with the UBE and would extend from elementary preparatory to elementary grade two to include primary grades three to five next year. He also put at ease the query of schools capacity by stating that free education would require additional classrooms, teachers, staff houses and school facilities.
“This is from preliminary scoping to establish that to holistically make free education policy work, we would need an annual budget of about K1.7 billion,” he said.
He called for development partners to lessen costs for building and refurbishing classrooms, teacher training and other school facilities including operational expenditures.
“We acknowledge that education is an inherent right and as a responsible government, we are giving free education to PNG that has started implementation in 2010 and should be fully implemented in 2013,” he said.

The National 29 June : PNG joins global effort on disability

PAPUA New Guinea is working towards achieving one of the nine recommendations formulated at a world disability gathering in New York on June 9.
The nine recommendations were:
* Accessibility to all mainstream systems and services, with stakeholders being encouraged to change laws and policies, institutions and environment;
* Investing in programmes and services for people with disabilities where specific measures such as rehabilitation, support services or vocational training to improve functions and disabilities to make them independent;
* Adopting a national disability strategy and plan of action;
* Involving people with disabilities to be at the planning level in formulating and implementing policies;
* Improving human resource capacity through effective education, training and recruitment;
* Providing adequate funding;
* Increase public awareness and understanding about disability;
* Improve the availability and quality of data on disability; and
* Strengthen and support research on disability as it increases public understanding, which, if supported through adequate funding, will make others appreciate and overcome social barriers.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/papua-new-guineas-poor-still-waiting-fair-share accessed 30 June

Papua New Guinea’s poor still waiting for a fair share

Thirty-six years after the people of Papua New Guinea gained the right to govern themselves they are still waiting on a government that gives them a fair share of the country’s considerable resources.

“We have so much need for basic government services  in the midst of the all mines, all the riches being extracted from our land,” says Ombudsman John Toguata.

From the conflict over the Panguna mine in Bougainville until today, the story has remained the same – one resource project after another resulting in  landowner discontent over the failure to divide up the royalties properly and fairly.

PNG’s resource laws and its tendency to agree to bad deals are a contributing factor, but so is corruption.

For years now, politicians in Papua New Guinea have been more focussed on what they can take out rather than what they can put in.

A career in politics seen as an easy way to get rich quick but a new generation has emerged promising to do things differently.

Opposition leader Belden Namah says the failure to protect the landowners basic rights is the biggest issue currently facing PNG.

One change under serious consideration is a re-writing of PNG’s resource law which would see the country automatically own 20 per cent of each project, rather than having to purchase a 20 per cent share – as is currently the case.

“If the people see the benefit of these multi-billion operations going on in the country going back to them we will be dealing with a totally different situation,”, Toguata says.

From the Compendium of Social Doctrine of the Church.

Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace

IV. A COMMON RESPONSIBILITY

a. The environment, a collective good

466. Care for the environment represents a challenge for all of humanity. It is a matter

of a common and universal duty, that of respecting a common good, destined for all,

by preventing anyone from using “with impunity the different categories of beings,

whether living or inanimate – animals, plants, the natural elements – simply as

one wishes, according to one’s own economic needs.” It is a responsibility that

must mature on the basis of the global dimension of the present ecological crisis

and the consequent necessity to meet it on a worldwide level, since all beings are

interdependent in the universal order established by the Creator. “One must take

into account the nature of each being and of its mutual connection in an ordered

system, which is precisely the ‘cosmos.”‘

This perspective takes on a particularlmportance when one considers, in the

context of the close relationships that bind the various parts of the ecosystem, the

environmental value of biodiversity, which must be handled with a sense of responsibility

and adequately protected, because it constitutes an extraordinary richness

for all of humanity. In this regard, each person can easily recognize, for example,

the importance of the Amazon, “one of the world’s most precious natural regions

because of its bio-diversity which makes it vital for the environmental balance of

the entire planet.” Forests help maintain the essential natural balance necessary for life. Their destruction also through the inconsiderate and malicious setting

of fires, accelerates the processes of desertification with risky consequences for

water reserves and compromises the lives of many indigenous peoples and the

well-being of future generations. All indiviquals as well as institutional subjects

must feel the commitment to protect the heritage of forests and, where necessary,

prom

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – May 2011

Social Concerns Notes – May, 2011

http://www.rnzi.com/pages/news.php?op=read&id=60325 accessed 2 May

Papua New Guinea told a whole of government solution needed to booze problem

The deputy leader of the Papua New Guinea opposition, Bart Philemon, says the country’s problems with alcohol cannot be addressed on a piecemeal basis.

Mr Philemon says PNG needs a national policy on how to cope with what a recent report called a culture of intoxication.

He says as well as better enforcement and new legislation, it involves changing attitudes to alcohol and this would need a whole of government approach.

 

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/will-papua-new-guinea-benefit-or-lose-out-commodity-boom accessed 4 May

Will Papua New Guinea benefit or lose out in the commodity boom?

By Paul Barker, Director of the Institute of National Affairs*

Papua New Guinea is experiencing a boom associated with LNG development and record prices for most of its mineral and agricultural products. One might expect the country’s population to be thriving from this, with the benefits extending right out to rural communities. Whilst some individuals and businesses are certainly doing nicely from prevailing conditions, most of the population (and many businesses) are either left out, or unable to take advantage of current or forthcoming opportunities, or in some cases worse off

The weak link is a failing State with its severely underperforming institutions, which struggle from poor leadership, poor coordination, low morale, corruption and in many cases inadequate resources for the tasks they face, particularly after years of neglect and poor oversight, and now with greater competition from the private sector for certain key skills, from engineers to doctors, (with even the latter being hired in numbers -for a premium -by PNGLNG). This incapacity of the State severely undermines the extension of development opportunities and benefits through the economy, across the provinces and the community, notably by failure to provide critical public goods, notably maintaining vital access roads and other infrastructure and services, including addressing burgeoning crime, whilst often diverting effort and resources into marginal or inappropriate activities. This must be addressed now, or LNG and other major resource development will indeed be more of a curse than a benefit.

Unfortunately, we will not see improvements in government performance (despite the efforts of many dedicated individuals within the public sector) until the the public stops kowtowing to non-performing leaders, stands up and holds government and individual leaders accountable for the use of public funds (including by State enterprises), and stops seeing government and politicians as the provider of jobs and cash handouts to wantoks and political cronies, or demanding unjustified compensation or out of court settlements. …

http://pngexposed.wordpress.com/2011/05/12/is-rimbunan-hijau-pulling-waris-strings-again/ accessed 12 May

Is Rimbunan Hijau pulling Wari’s strings again?

Secretary of the Department of Conservation, Wari Iamo, has given the government a submission recommending that rather than a Commission of Inquiry, he should conduct an investigation into the controversial Special Purpose Business and Agriculture leases.

The idea that either the Department of Conservation, or the Office of Climate Change, which Iamo also heads, should do an inquiry is completely laughable. These departments are completely under-resourced, have no capacity to do a review of 74 separate leases and, especially in the case of DEC,  they can’t even do their mandated work.

Even worse, Iamo and DEC are intrinsically involved in the granting of Forest Clearance Authorities that allow clear-fell logging within the SABLs. DEC grants the environmental permits, Iamo signs them and then, in his role on the National Forest Board, Iamo gets to approve the FCA!

The question is whether Iamo’s lame intervention is an attempt to save his own skin by preventing his role in the SABL scandal being revealed in the Commission of Inquiry – as was suggested on this blog yesterday – or is he acting on behalf of his old friends at Rimbunan Hijau?

 

http://www.canberratimes.com.au/news/opinion/editorial/general/neither-major-party-treats-asylumseekers-as-people/2158099.aspx accessed 11 May

 

REFUGEES – PNG PRIORITY(10 May)

Will the Government, in its negotiations to set up a refugee processing centre in PNG, discuss the situation of about 10,000 refugees who are already in PNG? People who fled from West Papua in the years following the Indonesian invasion in the late 1960s are living in camps or surviving in uncertainty, hardship and fear in shelters along the PNG-Indonesian border or in urban areas. Surely facilitating the resettlement of these long-suffering refugees should be a priority.

 

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/media-watch-who-pulling-nationals-strings-sabls accessed 9 May

Media Watch: Who is pulling The National’s strings on SABLs?

The National newspaper, owned by Malaysian logging giant Rimbunan Hijau, seems to be struggling to present a fair and balanced coverage of the issue of Special Purpose Agriculture and Business Leases (SABLs).

On Thursday, May 5, Papua New Guinea’s Acting Prime Minister, Sam Abal issued a press statement just before 4pm, announcing a Commission of Inquiry into the controversial issuing of SABLs covering over 5.2 million hectares of customary land.

This was BIG news. The issue of the leases, PNG’s biggest ever land-grab, has been ever- present in the media over the last month, attracting the attention of academics, scientists, landholders, politicians, commentators NGOs, politicians and even the United Nations High Commission on Indigenous Rights.

Radio stations immediately began running the PM’s announcement on their hourly news bulletins from 4pm, it was featured on EMTVs flagship evening news program at 6pm. On Friday morning the Commission of Inquiry was front page news in the Post Courier newspaper.

But the story was totally ignored by The National, PNG’s other daily newspaper. This silence was quickly commented upon by Prof William Laurance, a scientist at James Cook University and a member of the Association for Tropical Biology and Conservation, which has taken a strong stand against SABLs:

This analysis was reinforced today, Monday, when the announcement of the Commission of Inquiry was finally acknowledged in The National, albeit in a story on page 13 of the newspaper, while a statement by Opposition MP, Belden Namah, condemning the Inquiry, featured much more prominently on page 3!!

One of the criticisms of SABLs is that they are a mechanism for the logging industry to gain access to vast areas of forest which they can clear fell without any oversight from the PNG Forest Authority. Rimbunan Hijau has been frequently linked with illegal and unsustainable logging and human rights abuses in Papua New Guinea but has always been staunchly defended in it own newspaper.

 

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 16 May

Pacific people struggle against oppression

BY PUI-YI CHENG

AS THE WORLD’S ATTENTION focuses on human rights in the Middle East and North Africa, Amnesty International’s latest report reveals Pacific people are facing the same struggle against oppression and corruption.

On the eve of its 50th anniversary, AI has launched its annual assessment of human rights worldwide, Amnesty International Report 2011: State of the World’s Human Rights, which documents abuses in 157 countries in 2010.

“Away from the international headlines, thousands of people in the Pacific are being denied social and economic opportunity, and human rights defenders have been threatened, imprisoned and tortured,” says Patrick Holmes, chief executive officer of Amnesty International in NZ.

In PNG, violence against women and sorcery-related killings continue to be widespread but the government has done little to address them. Torture and ill-treatment of prisoners remains pervasive.

Source: Pacific Media Watch

 

Post Courier 17 May: Abal: Govt stops cash handouts

A TOTAL of K536 million has been paid out to honour memorandum of agreement commitments in the Southern Highlands and related project areas.
This time around though, the final payments will not be in cash anymore.
And in about two days time, the National Executive Council will release the new formula which will be used to pay the money through development projects.
This new approach was announced yesterday by Acting Prime Minister, Sam Abal, who said a new process had been finalised and was ready to be implemented.
He said over the years, the people’s money had been going down the drain including the K536 million.
He said the new policy for release of MoA funds centred on the consideration that the money was going to fund projects in some of the most remote areas in the country.
He said the Government was determined to ensure that the money promised to the people went to tangible development projects and “not converted into cash”.

The National 17 May: PNG among oppressed island nations

AS the world’s attention focuses on the human rights revolution sweeping across the Middle East and North Africa, Amnesty International’s (AI) latest report reveals Pacific people, including Papua New Guineans, are facing the same struggle against oppression, tyranny and corruption.
On the eve of its 50th anniversary, AI last week launched its annual assessment of human rights worldwide, Amnesty International Report 2011: State of the World’s Human Rights, which documents abuses in 157 countries last year.
A section dedicated to PNG noted that violence against women and sorcery-related killings continued to be widespread but the government had done little to address them.
“Torture and ill-treatment of detainees and prisoners were prevalent.
“Police often beat detainees with gun butts and knives, and raped or sexually abused women detainees,” AI reported.
It said that violence against women continued to be widespread, perpetuated by women’s low status in society and traditional practices such as polygamy and bride price.
“A culture of silence and impunity prevailed, and women remained fearful of reporting sexual and physical violence to the authorities.”
AI took note of the recent visit by the UN Special Rapporteur on torture who found that women were at a very high risk of abuse in the private and public spheres.
During arrest and detention, police officers tortured and ill-treated women, subjecting them to sexual abuse – it appeared that police frequently arrested women for minor offences with the intention of sexually attacking them.
Police punished women detainees by placing them, or threatening to place them, in cells with male detainees, where many were gang-raped.
Last July, while reviewing PNG’s CEDAW obligations, “the CEDAW committee expressed its deep concern at the persistence of sexual violence at domestic and community levels and at the lack of data on its nature, extent and causes. A government representative promised the Committee that the government would legislate against domestic violence”.

The National 19 May: Govt urged to involve church

By ALISON ANIS
THE government needs to work in partnership with the churches and other relevant authorities in successfully implementing health policy and guidelines, health secretary Dr Clement Malau says.
He acknowledged the churches’ role in implementing health services in the country, saying the partnership with the churches in PNG was critical to realising the national health plans.
“Partnership with the churches is important in implementing health policy,” he said.
“We acknowledge this is not a job for health department alone and that working in partnership with relevant authorities like churches is what we need in making the health system work,” Malau said at the 43rd annual conference of Churches’ Medical Council.
He said the department was looking to see how churches could be represented meaningfully on the single health authority system proposed under the national health plan.
Malau said the single health authority would replace the current system that operated in line with the organic law on provincial government and local level government.
He said having a single authority was good and would prove effective rather than a fragmented health system with undefined responsibilities.
Malau said the government was looking at ensuring equity and access to health services for all citizens.

 

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 23 May

Carterets: islands disappearing under the sea

BY TARA JONES

THE CARTERET ISLANDS, east of Bougainville, are threatened by a rapidly rising ocean. Forced to relocate, the Carteret Islanders are trying to find ways to preserve their culture for future generations.

This has caused the population to become one of the first indigenous cultures forced to prepare for and implement measures for the permanent resettlement of their entire community.

Relocation of the islanders into communities that are geographically, culturally, politically and socially different will make the preservation and continuation of their culture and unique cultural identity difficult.

 

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 24  May

Porgera landholders appeal to United Nations for support

A recent landmark decision of the National Court in Papua New Guinea that gives Porgera Joint Venture Company exclusive rights of occupancy to its Special Mining Lease (SML) could affect thousands of landowners living in major resource development project areas throughout the country. Meanwhile, landowners from Porgera have traveled to the United Nations to advocate for the humane resettlement of the people still living within the SML.

The lawsuit, against the Wapini sub-clan living in the SML area of Barrick Gold’s Porgera mine, sought permanent injunctions against the landowners who were continually tearing down a fence that the company was building around the SML.

The lawyer representing the Wapini landowners, submitted on behalf of the landowners that the company was constructing the fence through their village and this would result in their displacement, as well as destruction to their homes, food gardens and economic trees. The resettlement of people still living inside the SML area of the Porgera Mine has been a key demand brought by the landowners association for many years. “We are forced to live like squatters in our own land. The company’s mining activity, through the mine waste and now this giant fence, has overtaken all of the land that we once used to live in and grow food,” said Mark Ekepa, chairman of the Porgera Landowners Association. “With this legal decision, the national government is legitimizing Barrick’s use of force in evicting indigenous landowners from their own land. We have no where to go, so we are taking our struggle to international bodies” “Our government is weak and depends on companies like Barrick to provide revenues from resource extraction,” said Jethro Tulin of the Porgera Alliance. “While we try to work with our government in PNG, we find that the government speaks like the company and the company speaks like the government. Meanwhile, there’s a human rights crisis on the ground that neither body wants to acknowledge.”

 

The National 24 May: Kerema faces food crisis

By JUNIOR UKAHA
PUBLIC servants and their families in Kerema town, Gulf, are facing a food crisis after major shops in the township shut down because of the lack of banking services.
The only bank in town – Bank South Pacific – has been closed since 2008 after it was allegedly robbed by convicted bank robber William Nanua Kapris and his gang.
Kerema police station commander Insp Heni Vagi said, since last week, public servants and their families had been travelling to Port Moresby to shop. “Basic commodities like rice, tinned fish and meat, sugar and salt are out of stock in all stores,” Vagi said. “Major shops have closed their doors because they have run out of food,” he said.

 

The National 24 May: Kanawi: Denying condom use could be criminal act

DENYING a person the right to use a condom and other protective methods especially if the partner is HIV positive is a criminal offence under the HIV/AIDS Management and Protection (HAMP) Act, National AIDS Council director Wep Kanawi said.
“The National AIDS Council, under section 11 of the HAMP Act, has the authority to take to court HIV positive individuals who are denying others the use of condom when engaging in sexual activities,” he said. …

http://malumnalu.blogspot.com/2011/05/new-antivenom-will-save-lives-in-papua.html#links accessed 24 May

New antivenom will save lives in Papua New Guinea

For the past several years, a small group of Papua New Guinean researchers, led by an Australian scientist, working inside a modest unassuming brick building in a quiet corner of the University of PNG’s Taurama Medical School have helped develop a new treatment for one of PNG’s most-neglected public health problems.

This week their work has emerged into the international spotlight following publication in a prestigious medical journal of the first results in the testing of a new Papuan taipan snake antivenom which is hoped will save hundreds of lives every year.

Papua New Guinea has some of the highest snakebite rates anywhere in the world, and in some parts of Central Province, the mortality rate is several times higher than malaria, TB and pneumonia death rates, largely because a lack of interest in the problem has made access to safe, effective treatments scarce, and unaffordable.

 

Post Courier: 25 May DSIP scam rampant!

THE public money scam plague that is reaping funds from the District Services Improvement Program (DSIP) is of epidemic proportion.
The scam includes ghost bank accounts being set up, deposits made and cleared in record time, and then closed after complete withdrawal of all proceeds without a trace of the depositors or owners. The scam was so rampant there was actually no record of how many there are in the country. This was the grim reality and picture painted for Parliament yesterday by National Planning Minister, Paul Tiensten, who said it involved a host of central government agencies, departments, commercial banks and private sector connections.
He said this after Parliament was told by Jimi Open MP, Waka Goi, of persistent attempts to rip him off of K8 million for his district market and K4.8 million for his local high school by unknown persons who asked for kick-backs if they facilitated the payments for him.

Post Courier, letters: Quick action on outbreak

THE Catholic Health Services (Diocese of Bereina) last month reported a suspected outbreak of whooping cough in the Woitape Local Government Area of Goilala District in Central Province.
Ten (10) deaths were recorded as suspected pertussis or whooping coughs by staff at Ononge and Woitape health Centres. More deaths were reported in the villages and these were now being verified. The Onongwe Health Centre had reported a large number of patients coming with whooping cough symptoms.
Central Province Division of Health quickly established a program of activities to respond to the outbreak, by despatching six teams to the affected areas.
These teams provided treatment for those people who were ill and also did vaccinations and providing health information to the people in those remote communities.
They also took some specimens which had been conveyed to the Central public health laboratory for confirmation testing.
Central Province Administration responded quickly and made funds available for the rapid respond that was required containing the suspected outbreak. Unfortunately, communications to this remote area were limited, and also the Provincial Administration was working closely with National Department of Health and other partners to make sure that the response was well-coordinated and effective.

Michael Uaiz
Acting Provincial Health Adviser.

 

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/world/nothing-to-show-as-png-loses-250m/story-e6frg6so-1226062938977 accessed 26 May

Nothing to show as PNG ‘loses’ $250m

Rowan Callick, Asia-Pacific Editor , From: The Australian

THE Papua New Guinean government has lost almost $250 million intended for community projects in areas affected by the development of a $16 billion ExxonMobil-led liquefied natural gas plant and by nearby oilfields.

Acting Prime Minister Sam Abal revealed this week that after almost 10 years of such payments, “there is nothing to show, except a few incomplete projects”. He admitted much of the money had been misused and said these “memorandum of agreement” projects would now be managed by the government-owned Mineral Resources Development Company.

He said the government’s renewed promise to deliver community and infrastructure projects in the gas and oil areas “is not a commitment by the government to write cheques to landowner associations and companies for projects that were never built”.

The disappearance of these funds has triggered growing hostility among landowners yet to see benefits of the massive gas deal, which is now approaching full-scale construction.

 

Post Courier 26 May : Bishop unveils mental health policy

MENTAL health is about one’s everyday life, including how he or she relates to others and how a person feels about him or herself.
And yet, this is the most neglected aspect of health in the country, resulting in lack of services such as rehabilitation programs for people struggling with drug related problems.
But designers of the country’s first ever National Mental Health Policy launched in Port Moresby on Tuesday hope this will change in the coming years.
Catholic Archbishop of Port Moresby John Ribat, when launching the policy, also said mental health was about everything, peace of mind, happiness, satisfaction and so on.
“It is about how we feel about ourselves, how we feel about people around us, and how we meet the demands of people,’’ he said.
He was speaking during the mass he celebrated at St Joseph Catholic Church in Boroko to launch the policy, attended by Governor-General Sir Michael Ogio, representatives of the National Health Department, PNG Churches Alliance and teachers and students of St Joseph Primary School. …

Post Courier, 27 May editorial: ABG walking tightrope

BOUGAINVILLE leaders are faced with quite a sticky problem at present.
A faction of the rebel army that waged a 10-year armed rebellion against the Government of Papua New Guinea and authority in Bougainville is on the loose, it seems. The faction, led by Damien Koike, is once again striking fear in the heart of people in South Bougainville. Yesterday, they are reported to have conducted an ambush and shot dead two innocent people. Three weeks ago, the group declared war on the Autonomous Bougainville Government led by John Momis. Immediately after that, another group under the command of former Bougainville Revolutionary Army heavy, Ishmael Toroama, ran a campaign of terror in Panguna over a couple of days, firing gun shots into premises of businesses trying to start up in Panguna. …

 

Post Courier 27 May: MOA funds to MRDC

By Jonathan Tannos

MORE than K600 million paid out by the Government as Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) funds for projects in resource project areas since 2001 were thrown into a black hole.
And Acting Prime Minister Sam Abal is adamant that this will not be repeated. Millions of Kina will no longer go into the hands of landowners but will be managed by a Project Management Unit (PMU) under the roof of the Mineral Resources Development Company.
Australian engineering firm, Snowy Mountains Engineering and Consultancy (SMEC), have been engaged by MRDC to prepare an operation manual for the PMU, which will be manned by a team of qualified engineers, project managers and secondees from Oil Search Limited’s tax credit scheme to implement the MOA projects.
This will apply to all PNG LNG project areas and impact communities, Mr Abal said on Wednesday.
The commitments have been clearly identified and categorised into outstanding ones under existing MOAs from the Kutubu project and those under the new LNG development.
“It is not a commitment by the Government to write cheques to landowner associations and companies for projects that were never built,” was the warning from Mr Abal.
“More than K600 million has been spent since 2001 and there was nothing to show for, except a few incomplete projects.”

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/corporate-laws-failing-protect-human-rights-papua-new-guinea accessed 29 May

Corporate laws failing to protect human rights in Papua New Guinea

There are no government administered policies, codes or guidelines in PNG related to corporate governance that would encourage companies to develop a corporate culture respectful of human rights.

That is the conclusion drawn in a review of corporate law and human rights in PNG conducted by international law firm Allens Arthur Robinson on behalf of the United Nations Human Rights Council.

The UN has recognised the duty of the state to protect against human rights abuses by corporations through appropriate policies, regulations and adjudication. This duty sits alongside the corporations responsibility to respect human rights and the rights of victims to greater access to effective remedies where their rights are breached.

In an attempt to understand how national laws and policies dealing with incorporation and listing; directors’ duties; reporting; stakeholder engagement; and corporate governance more generally require, facilitate or discourage companies from respecting human rights, the UN instigated a Corporate Law Project looking at the state duty to protect in forty different countries, including PNG.

 

http://www.pngblogs.com/ accessed 29 May

How can PNG fight the resource curse?

MATT MORRIS

Papua New Guinea is on the brink of it’s biggest resources boom. Will it be a curse or a blessing? A new generation of mining projects and a massive LNG project are expected to double the size of the economy over the next decade. Yet there is skepticism about whether benefits will be shared widely among the nation’s seven million people. This is the third resource boom in as many decades, and despite the promises of the past, incomes today are barely higher than they were at independence in 1975 and PNG is unlikely to meet any of the MDGs.

 

Some argue that PNG has a classic case of the resource curse: Dutch Disease, weak accountability and corruption, which all conspire to undermine economic, social and political development. A key question is how to break with this past experience and chart a new development path?

My view is that Dutch Disease and absorptive capacity aren’t the main problem. A great deal is already known about how to manage these, both in the context of scaling-up aid inflows and managing resources booms. (For more of this read Owen Barder’s paper on scaling-up aid and Menachem Katz’s book on managing the oil curse in Africa.)

Nor do I think a lack of planning is a big problem for PNG. The government has both long term and medium term development plans and a raft of sector and thematic plans, including one for the informal economy. We can debate whether or not these focus on the right policies, but most commentators would agree that the main problem is a lack of implementation.

There needs to be debate about and fine-tuning of macroeconomic policies and development plans, but the challenge is how to implement them and that brings us to the issue of governance, and the potentially corrosive impact of resource revenues on accountability, transparency and government capability in the delivery of services.

 

During the latest resources boom, indicators of the quality of governance declined. PNG is now in the bottom 5% of countries in terms of control of corruption. We need a lot more ideas on how to improve the accountability, transparency and government capability if we are to reverse this trend. …

The National 28 May: Committee discloses truth about missing millions

THE system of trust accounts into which millions of kina has been parked since 2006 has failed to ensure the proper and lawful handling of public monies or to effect government policy, the Public Accounts Committee has reported to parliament.
This had result in failed development and service delivery, it said.
Accounting of trust accounts in which some K6 billion of excess money from high commodity prices were kept and spent had collapsed by 2007 and had not improved to this year. PNG may never know how much exactly these windfall gains had evaporated since the last of these funds were expended in 2009.
The PAC reported widespread and significant misconduct, misappropriation and defalcation by trustees or signatories across the whole span of government from national agencies right down to the district level.
Not one agency of government complied with all trust accounting requirements and almost all obeyed none of the requirements and this situation still prevailed this year.

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201105/s3230211.htm accessed 30 May

PNG LNG boss speaks out on landowner issues

The boss of the massive ExxonMobil-led Papua New Guinea liquid natural gas project says it would be of great concern if landowners shutdown construction of the project.
Landowners from the Hela region in the PNG highlands have threatened to do just that if the PNG government does not deal with a long list of grievances.
With the death of a local Chief tensions are rising and landowners are saying immediate action is needed or the consequences will be serious.
GARRETT: So what is the PNG LNG project contributing to Papua New Guinea in terms of governemnt revenue, jobs and business opportunities?

GRAHAM: In the long-term the impact is quite substantial on the economy of PNG. ACIL Tasman did an independent study some years ago that suggested GDP would double as a result of the project and, I think, over the life of the project the state take, or state revenue from the project, is something like $US30 billion – so very very substantial over the 30 year life of the project. But if you look just very near term at the impact of the project during the construction phase. Obviously there is a very large impact on employment. Today, we are employing something like five and a half thousand national citizens working on the project and we are spending substantial amounts of money in the country. To date its about K2 billion or around $800 million dollars has been spent project to date, has been spent actually in PNG. You only have to look around the country to see the positive impact the project is having. The biggest challenges, I think, are really land access looking foward, to make sure that we have continuing access to the land and an ability to get on and deliver the contruction part of the project on time. We have an election which is coming up next year in mid-2012. In some ways the timing of that could not be much more challenging – it happens to be at the same time that our construction activities peak and typically that is a change in the pace of life for people in the communities. So we’ve got a few issues like that that sit out in front of us that – again its getting access to land and security within the communities within which we operate. We know how to execute a project, or more correctly our contractors do, it is just executing the project in the context of Papua New Guinea.
GARRETT: In terms of the landowner isues – what would you like to see the government do to lift its game?

GRAHAM: I think the best thing government can do right now is to put more people in the field and get the agencies talking with nthe landowners directly. I think that is the largest source of frustration that what landowners have felt obliged to do, is to come down from the field to Port Moresby and try and get access to people in Port Moresby. That is not the right answer. Government agencies need to be in the field dealing with people because that brings a natural transparency to that engagement between landowners and government. There are people who do come down from time to time who do not truly represent the people they claim to in the field, but if that consultation is done in the field it is done in the presence of the constitutents and that is important. …

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201105/s3230212.htm accessed 30 May

Reluctance in PNG to move against corruption – academic

 

PNG’s public finances are so badly recorded that only now has the Public Accounts Committee been able to hand down a report into the 2007 financial year. Committee chairman Martin Aini told parliament last Friday money had been spent in breach of the constitution and other laws, and bureaucrats had given themselves huge and illegal cash advances.

Post Courier  30 May: Health issues killing PNG

By SIMON ERORO

ONE third of all medical aid posts in the rural areas of PNG remain closed because of lack of trained staff and adequate supplies like basic drugs.
This startling revelation is made in provincial performance report presented to Parliament by provincial Affairs Minister Job Pomat on Friday. There are a total of 2526 aid posts in PNG and 828 of them were closed.
The report said aid posts should be staffed and opened and must be re-stocked every three weeks with all necessary supplies. Information received from provinces showed that on average basic medical supplies were available at aid posts only during seven months in 2007, It also highlighted that it is critical that labour wards at health centres where women give birth have running water to minimise infections and maternal and child mortality because information showed 228 health centres out of 525 did not have adequate water supply.
The report stated that PNG is rated very poorly in the Pacific region on maternal mortality.

 

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – April 2011

Social Concerns Notes – April 2011

 

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 30 Mar

PNG Attitude: Strong economic performance continues

WORLD BANK

PNG’s STRONG ECONOMIC performance continued in 2010, supported by resurgent minerals production and investment in new projects.

GDP is expected to have expanded by 7%, following 5.5% growth in 2009. After contracting 1.8% in 2009, minerals output is estimated to have expanded by 5.4% in 2010, despite strikes affecting major mines in the first months of the year.

Activity in the non-minerals sector also accelerated, expanding overall by 8.2% in 2010 following 5.3% growth in 2009. This upturn was led by sectors most linked to minerals production and the growing income streams they are generating. Construction, manufacturing and retail trade all recorded 20-30% increases. Activity in the transportation and communications sector, which benefited from deregulation earlier in the decade, is estimated at have grown by near 16% in 2010.

The large PNG-liquefied natural gas project moved towards full construction phase, but suffered temporary disruptions due to landowner actions. Construction of the $15 billion project’s first phase is scheduled to complete by mid-2014, although there are risks of this slipping.

Local landowners have slowed or temporarily halted construction work at various sites in recent months. These interventions generally relate to alleged grievances regarding payment of land use compensation and business development grants by the central government to landowner groups. The central government has started distributing funds and has announced spending plans in anticipation of the PNG- LNG revenues.

Other announcements include a K157 million plan to build a national broadband network, piggybacking on the LNG fibre-optic cable.

The strong growth in construction and investment activity is creating capacity constraints and inflationary pressures.

Supply limits are being reached in particular sectors, such as property in Port Moresby and Lae, skilled labour, construction equipment and shipping facilities.

Businesses with looser budget constraints—generally the minerals investors themselves—are able to secure supplies and skilled labour by bidding up prices. Established firms, including the public sector, face growing difficulty in retaining staff.

Optimism continues to surround PNG’s medium-term economic outlook, but the risks are significant, as the government recognises. Growth is expected to slow modestly from recent strong rates.

 

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/women-and-children-fear-eviction-homes-fenced-first-sez accessed 31 Mar

Women and children fear eviction as homes fenced in for first SEZ

By Joshua Arlo*

Women and children from the Rempi area of Madang fear eviction as the government presses ahead with plans for Papua New Guinea’s first Special Economic Zone.

Together with their men, the women met to air their grievances about the government sanctioned US$300 million Pacific Marine Industrial Zone which promises to bring in 10 new fish canneries and about 30,000 jobs.

The Pacific Marine Industrial Zone is a special economic zone development driven by the national government of PNG. PMIZ will add to the existing RD Tuna cannery plant which has been in the province for the last 15 years. PMIZ was first introduced as a ‘marine park’ concept but now appears to be much larger in scope, incorporating a new shipping dock and other industrial developments as part of the SEZ. … Local families are confused and upset after hearing that they may have to be evicted from their homes because they have found out their land is no longer theirs but RD Tuna’s. …

http://malumnalu.blogspot.com/ accessed 31 Mar

‘Dutch Disease’ a real threat to Papua New Guinea with gas project

By MALUM NALU
Bank of Papua New Guinea governor Loi Bakani today warned of the effects of the dreaded ‘Dutch Disease’ on the PNG economy, particularly agriculture, in light of the liquefied natural gas project.
Bakani made the warning at a workshop focusing on the impact of LNG on the PNG economy, with particular reference to agriculture.
World Bank country manager, Laura Bailey, also warned of the dangers of ‘Dutch Disease’ as she gave an international perspective on this.
‘Dutch Disease’, or the ‘resource curse’, refers to an economic condition where a mineral boom leads to an appreciation of the real exchange rate, which in turn depresses output in the tradeable sector, in this case, agriculture. … cont

 

PC 4 April: Maternal mortality on the increase

By BOLA NOHO

MATERNAL mortality in Papua New Guinea is increasing each year at a rate of 733 deaths in every 100,000 live births.
In both rural and urban commu-nities, up to about five women die every day due to maternal problems.
This ranked Papua New Guinea (PNG) as having the second highest rate of maternal mortality in the world after Afghanistan.
This was revealed by doctors and officers from the Department of Health (NDoH), Population Services International (PSI) and other partners last Friday on FM100’s Talk Back program. …

PC 4 April: Sir J: Lands dept giving PNG away

Fifteen per cent of the total land area in the New Ireland Province has been given away to foreign companies under the Special Agricultural and Business Leases (SABLs), the New Ireland Provincial Government has revealed.
“These leases are granted by the Lands Department with no consultation with landowners or provincial governments. And they are huge, so far six leases have been granted in New Ireland for a total of over 141,000 hectares, which is over 15 per cent of the total land area of New Ireland,” Governor Sir Julius Chan said on the weekend.
And the former Prime Minister has accused the Lands Department of “giving Papua New Guinea away to fly-by-night loggers”. …

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/landowners-announce-public-forum-pmiz accessed 5 Apr

Landowners announce public forum on PMIZ

Landowners living on and around the site chosen for Papua New Guinea’s first Special Economic Zone, the Pacific Marine Industrial Zone, have announced a three-day public forum to discuss their concerns about the project. Invitations to the event are being sent to among others, Madang Governor, MP James Gau, his predecessor and now Attorney General, MP Arnold Amet, World Bank representative in PNG, Laura Bailey and MP Gabriel Kapris, the Minister for Trade and Industry. …

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 5 Apr

Seabed mining a risky business says expert

By PETER KORUGL

The Government is taking a big risk with its decision to take up its 30 per cent stake in the Solwara 1 project in the Manus Basin. This is the warning from one of Papua New Guinea’s leading expert on the Manus Basin, the site of the project operated by Nautilus Minerals Niugini Limited.

“Is the government well informed about the Solwara 1 project in Manus Basin before it decided to take up 30% equity in the project?” Dr Kaul Gena, lecturer at the Western Australian School on Mines, Curtins University asks.

Dr Gena, the only person in PNG who has explored the sea bed of the Manus Basin, said a lot of issues have been raised by different authors over the years but none of these issues has been addressed by Nautilus Mineral Niugini Limited.

Dr Gena said he would like to pose these issues again for the Government to consider.

  • What are current ore reserves of Solwara one project and its adjacent areas?
  • What mining methods are they going to use at 1700 metre depth when the ores are hosted by hard dacitic to rhyolitic lava?
  • The ores consist of lead and arsenic bearing minerals, what are the possible mitigation measures that the company will use to avoid environmental contaminations?
  • Where will the company process the ore and where will they dump the tailings? People leaving in areas adjacent to the processing plant will be subjected to lead poisoning like those in Mt. Isa and Esperance, Australia
  • The submarine hydrothermal sites are known to host very unique submarine organisms that host unique symbiotic microorganisms that are noble to understanding the evolution process. How will the company preserve such organism when it is destroying its habitat?

These are some very important questions that need to be addressed by the Nautilus Minerals Niugini Ltd and its joint venture partners….

 

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/central-bank-governor-sounds-warning-trust-funds-and-lng-impacts accessed 6 Apr

Central Bank governor sounds warning on trust funds and LNG impacts

The Central Bank governor has warned the government that its opaque management of trust funds could seriously undermine Papua New Guinea’s economic future.

In his latest bi-annual statement [attached below] the governor, Loi Bakani, says the government has already reneged on a promise to open all new trust accounts at the Central Bank, and K103 million from the K592 million announced in the 2010 Supplementary Budget has not been deposited with the Bank.

In addition, the government still has K2.243 billion, including numerous trust accounts, deposited in the commercial banks. Bakani says these funds must be transferred to the Central Bank otherwise its ability to support monetary policy management and control inflation will be impeded.

The Central Bank is warning that a fast draw down of the trust account funds and high government spending, especially on LNG landowner-related payments will impact liquidity and increase inflation.

The Central Bank wants close monitoring of all government trust accounts ‘to ensure proper application of the funds’. But the government is, so far, refusing to cooperate.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/landowners-warn-civil-unrest-if-dodgy-99-year-leases-over-customary-land-are-not-nullified accessed 6 Apr

Landowners warn of Civil Unrest if dodgy 99 year leases over customary land are not nullified

15 Landowner representatives from Western, Gulf, Oro, Milne Bay, Sandaun, Central and East New Britain, gathered at the Holiday Inn for 3 hours yesterday, at a media event giving prominence to the PNG government’s issuance of 99 year Special Agricultural Business Leases over more than 5 million hectares of customary land throughout PNG.

The media event, organised by PNG Eco-Forestry Forum  (PNGEFF) and Centre For Environmental Law and Community Rights (CELCOR), was purposely to bring media attention to the plight of landowners who have been caught unawares by dealings involving politicians, bureaucrats and dodgy foreign companies over their customary land.

http://www.pngblogs.com/ accessed 6 Apr

Understanding the PNG Medium Term Development Plan (MTDP)

Development Policy Centre

 

Papua New Guinea has no shortage of plans, visions, strategies and policy papers. Some are good, some are bad. All suffer from poor implementation. Despite the plans, and despite PNG’s mineral booms, the sad truth is that Papua New Guinean incomes, adjusted for inflation, have barely risen since independence. …

 

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/how-papua-new-guinea-government-taking-your-land accessed 7 Apr

How the Papua New Guinea government is taking your land

Special Agriculture Business Leases (SABL) is the new method the Papua New Guinea Government is using to take land away from customary owners. The leases are granted for 99 years without the knowledge and consent of landowners. In 2010, more than 2 million hectares was stolen, bringing the total area lost to more than 5 million hectares since 2001. The common scenario: landowners are promised agriculture projects on their land but the company also says they need to clear-fell the forest in order to develop the land. Before you know it, the company has harvested logs and is making its way to new areas leaving nothing behind, but to add to the insult, the 99-year lease means landowners lose control of their land for three generations!

 

 

There is a massive land grab happening in Papua New Guinea, according to a leading Australian academic.

In a paper to be delivered at a conference in London Australian National University Associate Professor, Colin Filer, says 5 million hectares of customary land has passed into the hands of national and foreign corporations in PNG using a legal mechanism called the ‘lease-lease-back scheme’.

That land amounts to 11 per cent of PNG total surface area and is twice as much has has been lost to corporate interests in 5 African countries where land aquisition is regarded as a major problem.

 

Presenter:Geraldine Coutts

Speaker:Associate Professor Colin Filer, Australian National University

 

FILER: It’s a rather complicated piece of legislation, but basically it allows the customary owners to lease land to the state and agree for the state to lease it back to a body which they approve of which could be a private company. And what we’re seeing is that 5.1 million hectares, about 11 per cent of the total land area has been leased back to private companies in this way since 2003, so that’s how it works. Why is it a problem? There are two aspects to the problem. One is have the customary owners really consented to this arrangement and what is actually going to be done with land? The question of what is being done with the land is basically coming down to the likelihood that most of it is going to be logged on the understanding that it will then be converted to some kind of agricultural development, but the prospect of the agricultural development seems a little bit shaky, which comes back to the question of whether the landowners knew that it would be shaky when they agreed to lease their land to the state in the first place.

 

COUTTS: It seems that the land is going to corporate entities, will the landowners get adequate share of the profits?

 

FILER: Well, possibly not, if the deal is the logging activity will fund the agricultural development, then it’s quite likely that the landowners would have been persuaded if they were agreeable that they would forego the benefits they would have got from the logging in order for those benefits to be invested in the agricultural development, but if the agricultural development doesn’t happen, then they might just make a loss on the whole venture.

 

COUTTS: Well, under these lease backed schemes, how long are they, the leases actually fall. will the landowners lose the say in the right over their own land for how long?

 

FILER: In most cases, 99 years which is the maximum period allowed under the legislation as in most other countries where these kind of leasing arrangements apply. So yeah, in most cases they would have given up their rights for 99 years, but whether anybody else could actually make use of the land for 99 years through some trading arrangement in the leases, well that’s a very open question. The customary owners are still sitting there in occupation of their land.

 

COUTTS: So what is actually driving the land grab?

 

FILER: Well, I think in most cases, it’s simply the interest of the logging industry in getting access to additional forest resources through this mechanism when in fact their ability to access resources through the forestry act and legislation is far more constrained and there is a real pressure on them to try and get that access quickly because of the prospective decline in the market for the sort of logs that Papua New Guinea export, which are things from many sources, because it’s likely to happen within the next two, three, four, five years or so.

 

COUTTS: How can this happen when Papua New Guinea has constitutional guarantees for customary land?

 

FILER: That’s a very interesting question, because here I am at the conference in Europe, where everybody is saying kind of the land grab that’s happening in Africa or Latin America because the state ultimately owns the land and customary rights are not protected. So Papua New Guinea is an unusual case where there is this legal protection of customary rights and yet these customary rights are being abrogated. So is it simply the total corruption of the system or is it a degree of consent from the customary owners? This is a really interesting question.

 

COUTTS: Well, we’ve talked about some of the problems of the 99 year lease and the question mark over whether there’ll be other access given during that 99 years or whether the customary landowners lose it altogether. Is that the extent of the potential dangers of the lease backed scheme?

 

FILER: Well, look you can’t, I mean there is no serious prospects of customary owners being evicted from their land under these arrangements. They are simply not going to take it. They will resist if necessary with violence, so they will continue to occupy their customary land. The real question is will the arrangements produce any benefits for them. If they don’t, then they will simply ignore the arrangement and who is going to enforce the rights. I don’t think that the state and its police forces are going to be capable of doing that.

 

COUTTS: Well, if the demand is decreasing as you suggest and the logging supplies are also running out. What’s going to happen?

 

ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR FILER: Well, it’s not that the logs are running out, it’s mainly because the Chinese market for the logs which currently consumes 90 per cent of the logs that come from Papua New Guinea is by all accounts going to dry out because the Chinese themselves are investigating other ways of securing their raw materials and producing their furniture and so forth. So it’s a bit like what happened with the Japanese already. So word is that the Chinese market will dry up in which case the loggers have to get their logs to the Chinese market sooner rather than later, otherwise they’re won’t be a market.

 

COUTTS: So hence, the motivation for the land grab at the moment?

 

FILER: Yes, I think that’s the main driver of it.

 

COUTTS: What action should the PNG government and the landowners be taking to tackle the issue on their own behalf?

 

FILER: I don’t see any alliance there right now. I think interesting political consolation is that the sort of key players in the current national government are allied with various logging companies and so-called development partners to push these things through and there is sort of a growing opposition which involve not only environmental NGOs, but elements of the private sector, including the existing oil palm industry in Papua New Guinea, which has interests of its own to stop this happening and also significant elements of the public service, although they are to a degree silenced by the desires of their own political masters.

 

[Colin Filer’s 36pp paper on this topic is available at http://www.actnowpng.org/sites/default/files/The%20new%20land%20grab%20in%20Papua%20New%20Guinea%20Colin%20Filer.pdf ]

 

 

Report on Human Rights in PNG by the US State Department 8 April 2011

http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/hrrpt/2010/eap/154398.htm

“Human rights abuses during the year included arbitrary or unlawful killings by police, severe police abuse of detainees, poor prison conditions, police impunity, lengthy pretrial detention, infringement of citizens’ privacy rights, government corruption, violence and discrimination against women, sexual abuse of children, trafficking in persons, discrimination against persons with disabilities, intertribal violence, violence against Asians, and ineffective enforcement of labor laws”.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 19 Apr

Women taking action on climate change

WOMEN ARE ideally positioned to influence climate justice according to Oxfam Ireland and the Mary Robinson Foundation.

They are hosting international guests, including a woman from Bougainville, who are speaking about the impact of climate change on women’s lives and how women are acting to achieve climate justice.

“My elders and my community have given me a huge task,” said Ursula Rakova from the Carteret Islands in Bougainville.

“[I have] to tell the world what is happening on my island and what climate change is doing to destroy our lives. We are being forced from our ancient island homeland.”

Ursula is executive director of Tulele Peisa – “sailing the waves on our own” – a local community organisation that is trying to relocate the entire island community of the Carterets to nearby Bougainville because of the impacts of climate change.

“I would say to people who believe that climate change is not happening: if you have the heart to feel that you are flesh and blood, start to think about us on the island. What is a choice of lifestyle for you is a choice of life or death for us,” she said.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 21 Apr

It’s not the Chinese; the problem’s corruption

BY DAVID KITCHNOGE

THE ANTI-CHINESE sentiments that exploded into pockets of looting in various centres around PNG in 2009 must be properly analysed and addressed.

At the outset, let me say that the incidents of unrest were not acts of racism as some people would like us to believe. Any person from any country who has had the good fortune of engaging with Papua New Guineans at a personal level will tell you we are not racists.

Rather, the riots were a manifestation of a complete collapse of our governance systems over the years. It was always bound to happen the very first time corrupt Papua New Guinean officials colluded with foreigners in breaking our laws. If this is not clear enough, then we will truly miss a great opportunity to seriously address corruption in our country.

There is no one to blame for our predicament. As one of my friends said, the people have vented their anger at PNG and it was unfortunate that the China man was in its path. But, in saying that, I am not absolving the illegal Chinese immigrants of any wrong doing either.

Instead of pointing fingers, we must focus on fighting the root cause of the problem to avoid such resentment in future. And while we look at addressing corruption and its detrimental effects on our country, there are a number of things we should not ignore about the relevance of China to PNG.

 

http://bougainville.typepad.com/ accessed 21 Apr

NEW DAWN: end the killings
By Aloysius Laukai
ABG President, JOHN MOMIS is calling on all armed factional leaders in South Bougainville to work with him to end the terror in South Bougainville for good.
He made these remarks from Port Moresby that he wants the killing in South Bougainville to stop immediately.
He said that South Bougainville has seen too much death and injury from weapons and all leaders must unite to get rid of these deadly weapons.
MR. MOMIS said that the Bougainville crisis ended 14 years ago in 1997 and questioned why there was continuous killing in the Konnou constituency which has claimed more than 50 lives since 2006.
He said that these deaths in Konnou have nothing to do with the grievances that caused the Bougainville crisis.
MR. MOMIS said that the killings are the result of personal differences, lawlessness and criminal activity.

TN 20 April: ‘Outlaw sex crime compensation’

By JUNIOR UKAHA
Compensation paid for sexual crimes against children should be outlawed as it does not do justice to the victims, a workshop was told yesterday.
Eastern Highlands provincial government adviser John Sari told the “Restorative justice workshop” at the National Research Institute that justice was not done to victim of sexual abuse “if compensation is paid and the matter resolved out of court”.
He said while restorative justice aimed to resolve disputes out of court through other means, “cases involving sexual crimes against minors should never be entertained outside of the established court process”.
“When compensation is paid, the perpetrator escapes with his crime,” he said.

Personal Viability on Lihir – an opinion

The mining company at Lihir has provided substantial amounts of funding for the Personal Viability (PV) program in Lihir through the benefits package (hundreds of thousands of kina – and rising). During the renegotiation of the first benefits package (back in early 2000s), the local elite caught on to PV, and have since redefined the future for Lihir according to PV values/philosophies. This has been a somewhat remarkable achievement (compared to other landowner groups in PNG), especially, since they have been able to articulate a vision of the post-mining future based upon the idea that all Lihirians will become ‘PV literate’, and therefore supposedly self-sufficient. Their social and economic development plans that have been developed through the benefits package agreement are all structured around PV.

 

Needless to say this has been somewhat contested in Lihir, and not everyone is entirely convinced by the claims made by PV, or its founder, Sam Tam – who is now resides full time on Lihir to help usher in this cultural revolution imagined by the elite. All of this is funded through the benefits package – which speaks to a broader issue around governance of such agreements (and company responsibilities in this area). There is a high degree of scepticism among company management towards PV and Tam, but at the same time, management are caught between the need to ensure a degree of governance and control, and support local attempts at self-determination towards economic and social ends. The problem lies in the way that PV promises to do this, and the very cult-like ways that the local elite have latched on to PV (which is highly consistent with a history of Lihirian socio-political movements that were loosely aimed at unlocking the secrets of wealth. PV now appears to present Lihirians with the answers that were seemingly denied to them for so long – or at least that is how the elite see things here).

 

The catch cry of PV is ‘Are you viable?’ In Lihir, this has now been turned into the expression  (in English) ‘Are you congruent or incongruent with the Lihir Destiny?’ (the vision of the Lihir future that will only be possible through complete adherence to PV).

 

The GULL program was introduced here about a year or so ago. From what I can gather, it is designed to provide ‘formal’ qualifications for life experience. How this is intended to be useful I am not sure, except for perhaps concentrating people’s efforts on certain business/entrepreneurial tasks through this ‘everyday learning experience’.  With all these GULL and PV qualifications being awarded, Lihir is fast becoming an island of ‘Doctors’ and ‘Gold level PV members’. I think GULL was set up before any connection with PNG – which is why it is Californian based. The GG – Sir Paulias Matane – seems to be a big supporter, and according to the GULL website, was a founding chancellor of this alternative university. Similarly, the idea that the Grassroots University of Life would be set up on Lihir (and provide a basis for transforming the Pacific) is sits neatly with previous beliefs here about Lihir as the centre of the universe, and the idea that change will come here first, and then emanate out to the rest of the world – indeed the elite have used this as justification for their program.

http://asopa.typepad.com/ accessed 26 Apr

PNG Attitude: Land: questions of ownership & sovereignty

BY MARTYN NAMORONG

A RECENT PARLIAMENTARY review into mineral resource ownership and management has sparked a debate on transferring ownership from the State to so-called traditional landowners.

Proponents of this shift in ownership include prominent politicians and individuals. Their argument is straightforward: give customary landowners the right to ownership of what is under their land.

For many Papua New Guineans, this seems logical; after all, why should the State have ownership of resources that are under customary land? For millennia, their ancestors have fought to defend those tribal lands and the resources therein. Within their cultural context it seems totally unfair that the State should take away what they regard as their birthright.

The Bougainville crisis that stemmed out of such clash of cultures illustrates the extreme reaction of people towards the State. It is this principle of presumed traditional ownership that plagues the LNG Project in Southern Highlands Province.  … cont.

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201104/s3200246.htm accessed 26 Apr

PNG working to end scam in hospital medicine supply

For the past ten years there has been a sophisticated network in place providing huge kick backs from drugs meant for the PNG health service. It’s alleged the scam has been able to flourish with inside help and it’s further alleged that there has been at least one death threat against an official tyring to shut-down the illegal drug distribution. Authorities are working on strategies to prevent the corruption continuing.

…. MOLA: Various things have started happening as I said about I think ten years ago or so. One ploy has been to create an artificial shortage so that all of a sudden a hospital, a major facility hasn’t got something that’s absolutely critical to the service, like a very important antibiotic or something obstetrics to stop the women bleeding to death or something, and then all of a sudden you haven’t got it. And it’s almost contrived that we haven’t got it because we haven’t ordered enough or we haven’t distributed it properly. And when we run out we now have an emergency, and it’s a contrived emergency, so that now that we can buy locally for the emergency situation so we don’t have to go out to the tender process, we just have to get a couple of quotes from suppliers who are also in on all the corruption, so they just collude in providing inflated quotations and we get our emergency supplies three, four, sometimes ten times the value of the drugs. And then there’s a kickback of course from getting the emergency supplies under those circumstances.

COUTTS: So the people involved in the cartels are actually buying them sometimes at a cheaper price, inflating them as you suggest, and selling them for three and four times the original cost?

MOLA: This is sort of creating artificial emergencies so that there’s then no transparency in the quotation or pro-form, a sort of invoicing process, because we have so few wholesalers, I think there’s only about five wholesalers in the whole country, and it’s very easy for them to get together and collude in arranging quotes that are, like it’s your turn, so we’ll all put our prices up 20 times, and you just put yours up ten times this round and then we’ll take in turns to get the order next time, sort of thing. ….

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201104/s3200685.htm accessed 27 Apr

Former PNG PM wants resources to be owned by landowners

Updated April 26, 2011 16:23:53

A former prime minister of Papua New Guinea says the country’s traditional land owners should own the rights to the natural resources under their land. Sir Julius Chan, who is now governor of New Ireland Province, says the Bougainville crisis, which began as a dispute over who got the money generated by a huge copper and gold mine on the island, is an object lesson in what happens when people feel they are not getting the benefits they feel entitled to. He says his experiences as prime minister during that conflict have convinced him a change is needed in the law which grants the state the rights to PNG’s rich mineral deposits. Sir Julius says that landowners are quite capable of agreeing to mining leases, which would ensure the benefits go directly to local people rather than the government.

Presenter: Bruce Hill
Speaker: Sir Julius Chan, governor of New Ireland Province and a former prime minister of PNG

SIR JULIUS CHAN: I begin from the position that a country an independent state like Papua New Guinea cannot buy what it already own. The resources under the ground by virtue of the act of 1992 make the state the sole owner of anything below, above and in the water and out at sea. If you look at the history of Papua New Guinea for the last 35 years now. We’re approaching 36. With this kind of legislation, it has not proven any development in the lives of the people in Papua New Guinea. For some unknown reason and I must include myself here because of the infancy of self-government independence and haste in which we’ve acquired that. We legislated to restrict ourselves from ownership of this resources.

Let me put it in another way. Does it make any sense of business to transfer title in property to someone freely like foreign investors for paltry payment of ten-thousand kina and then when things are discovered buy back from them at 30 per cent or more for up to 300 million or more? It doesn’t make any sense. Now does it make any sense at all for a country to earn billions and we’ve earned that money in income and not being able to improve the lives of the people. I think if we ask those three questions, then we start thinking of the reason why I have chosen, transform the ownership of the resources back to the traditional landowners. I believe that the wealth of any country should be in the hands of the people so that when the people are rich, then a nation is rich.

HILL: But you were prime minister for a number of years, why didn’t you do something about that when you were in power?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: Yeah, you’re quite right and I admit it just then that I included, that because of the infancy of the period leading to the political status of our country, we don’t want to shake the boat in anyway or form and you can recall the Bougainville situation was created before self-government and independence, so we had that to follow. The pattern is already set for us and it was a colonial pattern that set the stage of the economic development of the resources in the hands of the state. So it was set by the colonial masters at that time.

HILL: And you weren’t able to do anything about it when you were in power, so what’s made you change your mind since then to really come down and say look, it really belongs to the traditional landowners, what changed your mind?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: Well it’s very simple, we didn’t have any more than Bougainville at that time. We now have major resources taking place, we have a lot of disputes going on and they will continue. Something must be wrong in the system of ownership, in defining the ownership of the land. So in this way, I totally disagree with Sir Arnold Ahmet that it should be held by the state, because the state has never solved these problems and you can see what is happening already with the LNG. We’ve lost a lot of lives already. Some are totally unreported, because places are so remote, but tribal fightings have increased. There is a lot of disputes and the closure of the reservoir now in Port Moresby. They’re all related to the ownership and the benefits of the traditional landowners.

HILL: But would that situation be better or perhaps worse if traditional landowners held the title to the resources?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: Well, if they’re involved, if they own the resources and be involved in the initial definition of their land and also involved in the establishment of the benefit sharing. I think at some point, we’ve got to give credit to the mothers and the fathers of Papua New Guinea that they will be more responsible in living up to the conditions that they themselves established, whereas now it’s completely different. It’s just been shoved down their throat!

HILL: But Sir Arnold Ahmed says it’s extremely difficult for that sort of a system to work because who would the people who wanted to extract the resources negotiate with. You have a plethora of tribes and clans and even when you reach an agreement, there’s always some other group of people says what about us we weren’t included? It can be very problematic negotiating with traditional landowners, because there’s no one address for that. There’s lots of people that you all have to sign up?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: That is correct and this exactly what is happening now. This is no solution. The state is doing just that negotiating with the landowners and owning the resources. I am saying that time has come to put the people, to accept their responsibilities, their ownerships of their resources, make decisions that affect them, that development and after the life of the mine. I believe that Papua New Guineans are no different to any other human beings on this planet. When they feel the ownership of the place, they’ll make responsible decisions, so I totally disagree with Sir Arnold Ahmet. It’s the only system that we’ve been used to and I think a change is required, because we have not improved the lives of the people. Now, we ought to take all these things totally into account. It’s not just a matter of building wealth, it’s the wealth is not improving the lives of our people and therefore there must be a big shift in the benefits of that wealth and it must be in the hands of the people, so that the grassroots have the opportunity to develop themself.

HILL: Is this the issue now more urgent to sort out because of the big LNG project and even larger projects in the pipeline which will involve not just millions of dollars, but billions of dollars. There’s a massive amount of money at stake here, isn’t there?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: Yes, yes, and there’s a massive discourse if nothing is resolved between now and the period of developing the oil and gas. So look, I think I’m not going to be very rigid in this, but I am going to say this, that we must research very deeply into the cause of all these problems and we must be prepared to make adjustment necessary to accommodate the development of the people with the current thinking of educated people coming up. I truly believe that the owners of these resources will change, will transform from the current, almost unsophisticated people in the hinterland, to the young, new generation of very educated people who will know the law, who will know that the customary law define the land that belongs to their group and they will accept the responsibility. I’m very certain this will happen with the new generation of young educated people.

HILL: How much of your thinking on this has been shaped by your experiences when you were prime minister dealing with what happened as a result of the copper mine on Bougainville and all the discord that happened as a result of that. Has this played a roll in your thinking about traditional ownership of resources?

SIR JULIUS CHAN: That is basically correct and as you can see there’s really what’s happened in Bougainville should be a lesson for all of us. It cost up to 15,000 lives lost and the Bougainvilleans, one of the sad, the resource, this is our custom, the resource on top, under, elsewhere belong to the people. They welcome the mine the Rio Tinto and Bougainville Copper to come in and develop it, but they want to make sure that they have the maximum share of that wealth and it is because of that that the Bougainville crisis flared up. It was not because of anything else. And I think it was speaking the truth, I think it was speaking the thinking behind every Papua New Guinean that the ownership of the resources must be in their hand, not the state.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – March 2011

Social Concerns Notes – March 2011

http://www.radioaustralia.net.au/pacbeat/stories/201103/s3153342.htm accessed 2 Mar

UN to investigate alleged PNG human rights violations

The United Nations has expressed concerns over claims Papua New Guinea security forces may have violated the rights of refugees from the Papua province of Indonesia.

It follows the removal of more than 100 West Papuans from settlements in PNG’s West Sepik province to a UN refugee camp in the Western province.

Presenter: Firmin Nanol
Speaker: Ms Walpurga Englbrecht, UNHCR’s PNG Representative

 

http://bougainville.typepad.com/ accessed 3 Mar

NEW DAWN: BISHOP ON MINE
By Aloysius Laukai

The Bishop of Bougainville, Bishop Bernard Unabali does not support the opening of so many mines on Bougainville.

He says that the island of Bougainville is very small and its environment can be destroyed if mining is allowed all over Bougainville.

The Bishop says that he will only support the opening of the Panguna mine if environmental issues along the tailings are properly addressed.

Bishop Bernard told reporters in Buka that he was concerned as the island could lose its forest, flora and fauna and the river systems if several mines were opened on Bougainville.

Meanwhile on the Chinese investments on Bougainville, Bishop Bernard also wants the ABG to set up a good policy that can attract investments on Bougainville.

He said that whilst the President may be dealing with credible organizations and companies now, other companies that would come in later may not be so good therefore a good policy can control these activities.

The Bishop of Bougainville said that to save guard Bougainville a good controlling mechanism must be established.

 

http://bougainville.typepad.com/ accessed 3 Mar

NEW DAWN: CHURCH MUST BE FULLY UTILIZED
By Aloysius Laukai

Bishop of Bougainville Diocese, BISHOP BENARD UNABALI is calling on the ABG to involve the Catholic church in many of its programs in the Autonomous Region of Bougainville .

He told a Press conference yesterday that many times the church is asked to assist when they face problems already.

Bishop Benard Unabali said that the church has more than One Hundred years of involvement with the people of Bougainville and should be taken on board as a major stakeholder.

He was commenting on the current discussions on Panguna where the church is again left out.

 

http://littlegreenpalai.blogspot.com/2011/03/kananam-landowners-question-ministers.html accessed 2 Mars

Kananam landowners question Minister’s interest to approve PMIZ

AMID resistance on the ground Minister for Environment and Conservation, Benny Allen is coming to Madang in March to ‘approve in principle’ the PMIZ project.
The people of Kananam are asking “what is the minister trying to do when we have outstanding issues with RD Tuna Canners and phase one of the PMIZ project? What is Mr Allen trying to do when the Environment Impact Statement (EIS) has not been properly explained to us?”
It seems the EIS is not able to suggest mitigation plans, so what is the minister thinking? Can the minister please explain to us what an ‘approval in principle’ is?
These and many other questions are boggling minds at Kananam but who will listen?
The awareness team was not welcomed on Krangket island for lack of transparency in the decisions regarding PMIZ and an attempt to make the people swallow a shallow awareness that the people knew already what it was trying to achieve. So what is the government trying to do now, when things are still not clear?, asks Mr Francis Gem, leader of Idawan Association of Kananam.
Mr Gem emphasized that all these talks about PMIZ must stop and current issues related to the initial stages of this project must be dealt with first.
Mr Gem said, there are no Memorandum of Understanding and there is no informed consent, so how can he (Mr Allen) want to approve the project? What is his interest in this project?

http://ramumine.wordpress.com/ accessed 9 Mar

Ramu mine has massive sulphuric acid plant

The processing plant for the Ramu nickel mine at Basamuk Bay in Papua New Guinea includes a sulphuric acid production unit that will produce a huge 3,350 tonnes of  98.5% pure sulphuric acid every day during the life of the mine.

The acid will be used in the high pressure acid leach, lime boil and solvent extraction stages within the refinery.

The acid production plant will be fed with 360,000 tonnes of sulphur per annum which will be bulk shipped to the processing plant.

Local landowners have recently been warned to stay out of the sea around the refinery site due to a chemical spill last week. They have also been told not to eat any food from the sea and not to do any fishing. Fish and other marine life are an important part of the diet for local people who rely on a traditional lifestyle.

http://www.pngblogs.com/ accessed 9 Mar

PNG Not prepared for LNG Impact  OP.ED

PAPUA New Guinea is ill-prepared for the impact of LNG. Up to now, the project has been thought of as something that might happen and that, if it did, it would impact the financial and economic sectors of the country and little else. Such thoughts are drawn from the shallow pool of ignorance and PNG pays a hefty price for ignorance.

Ill-prepared, both as a government and as a people, the full benefits of any resource project have overflown PNG entirely, leaving it to flounder in their wake and fighting over pet fodder such as royalties and taxes while the prized steak in substantial control and ownership and, in major spin-off contracts, have been left in the control of the multi-national conglomerates. Bougainville, Ok Tedi, Misima, Kainantu and Kutubu oil have come and go.

There is absolutely nothing to show for them. The reason is simply ignorance. Ignorance and a rather peculiar reluctance to learn from past lessons. That especial, if tragic, trait of PNG’s persists today and is about to hit PNG with the force of a tornado with the advent of the LNG project.

Nobody in this fair country will be untouched by its impact. Unless adequate protection is garnered on emergency footing right away, when the eerie peace and quiet that always comes in the aftermath of such a storm finally settles in 30 or so years, it will be upon a strange landscape – the same land but devoid of life and energy and filled with vultures, hyenas and carrion feeders of every kind that walks the earth. In another sense, PNG will never be the same again. The LNG projects, ExxonMobil’s as well as the one promoted by InterOil, will change the face of PNG.

As we have heard in the Asian inquiry, there are 14,000 applications for work permits alone from the LNG and only nine persons to process them. Word is now that when the project goes into full construction stage, there will be a need to process 50,000 visas. Is there capacity at the PNG immigrations and citizenship agency to process that kind of workload? Be sure that hiding among that throng coming in will be the vultures and the hyenas. They got to be stopped at the door.

The real estate industry in PNG is feeling the first direct impact of the project. The project has taken up most of the new residential buildings in Port Moresby at some previously unheard of sum per week for a unit. This has pushed up all other real estate prices so that housing, which has always been expensive, is now well beyond any individual – expatriate or national. Other industries will follow this upward trend. Already, in the Southern Highlands and elsewhere, schools are emptying of teachers as they seek hardship allowances and better terms and conditions of employment. They are not stupid.

Even unskilled labourers in the LNG project are getting paid double and triple the teachers’ salaries. This will have massive impact upon education. Students themselves will be reluctant to go to school. Education in PNG has always been promoted, quite wrongly as it turns out, as the way to a decent job and cash. Why go to school with so much money pouring out of the project? Remain ignorant and continue to be fed trash. Bad logic but immediately feasible and attractive – no work involved.

The agriculture and the fledgling manufacturing sectors, which have never received much attention in the past, will be the first lambs on the sacrificial altar. As the LNG project drives costs, including the cost of labour, up, it will become uneconomical to run factories or plantations. The cost of labour will be too expensive. Cost of factory inputs and fertilisers and fuel will go up. Factories will shut their doors and plantations and estates will be reclaimed by the bush.

For 30 years, nobody will notice – everybody being busy and employed. When the gas is all pumped out, that is when everybody starts looking around for the factories and the plantation sector and they will not be there. That is the phenomenon that is called the resources curse or the Dutch Disease.

By then, PNG will be permeated thoroughly with its contagion. A cash-rich nation will suddenly find, when the source of the cash is dried up, that there is no other source left to turn to.

The National 8 March: BSP: K283.15m net profit

BANK South Pacific posted an after tax profit of K283.15 million for the financial year 2010.
The bank also announced that its assets as of December last year were worth K8.655 billion, up 6% from December 2009.
BSP chairman Kostas Constantinou made the disclosure in a financial result submitted to the Port Moresby Stock Exchange.
The bank’s pre-tax profit was K402.10 million, up 6% from K377.96 million posted at the end of 2009.
http://www.actnowpng.org/content/pmiz-loan-china-terrible-deal-png accessed 11 Mar

PMIZ loan from China is a terrible deal for PNG

By PMIZ Watcher

The loan agreement signed between the Papua New Guinea government and China’s Eximbank, to fund development of the Pacific Marine Industrial Zone is a terrible deal for PNG. Putting aside the fact that PMIZ promises to be a disaster for Madang, repeating and expanding all the terrible social and environmental impacts of the existing RD Tuna fishing project, the US$70 million loan agreement signed with China means PNG will be paying for China’s continued economic expansion and business profits.

Interest and repayments

Like any loan, the PMIZ loan will have to be paid back and with interest added. Although the loan agreement gives PNG a five-year grace period before loan repayments start, that only adds to the length of the loan and the amount of interest that will ultimately accrue.

If PNG was serious about finding the money to pay for the PMIZ why not just plug a few of the holes in the Department of Finance through which billions of dollars of public money are being lost every year? PNG doesn’t need to be borrowing more money and we shouldn’t be saddling the next generation with more debt to repay.

Loan conditions

The loan conditions are where the real devil lies in this agreement.

The contract stipulates that 70 percent of the project (worth US$35 million) must go exclusively to a Chinese developer using Chinese technology, labour and equipment.

So the people of PNG will be paying for a Chinese company to come and build the Pacific Marine Industrial loan using Chinese labour and Chinese equipment and Chinese supplies. Where is the benefit here for PNG?

What about all the local people who would like the opportunity to be employed? What about all our college and university graduates without jobs? What about all the PNG based companies who could supply goods and equipment? But that is not all. Under the loan agreement the Chinese developer is guaranteed a profit of 20% – at least US$7 million! Why are people of PNG being forced to pay a guaranteed profit to a Chinese company?

It seems the PNG government have signed a loan agreement under which all the benefits will flow back to China and it is the people of PNG who are going to be paying to increase China’s economic wealth!  Why are people of PNG being forced to pay a guaranteed profit to a Chinese company?

It seems the PNG government have signed a loan agreement under which all the benefits will flow back to China and it is the people of PNG who are going to be paying to increase China’s economic wealth!

The National 10 March: Only 10 agencies accountable in 2009

TEN out of about 1,140 government entities in PNG have proven to be accountable in 2009 with their use of public money, as heard during a Public Accounts Committee (PAC) inquiry yesterday.
This was made known to the PAC late last year by the Auditor-General George Sullimann.
“Not one national government department, provincial government, local level government, hospital board or provincial commercial entity is included.
“Hundreds of audits were disclaimed for want of information, records, accounts, reposts and other legally required records,” the PAC stated.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/eis-paints-terrible-picture-pmiz-impacts accessed 17 mar

EIS paints a terrible picture of PMIZ impacts

By PMIZ Watcher

The Environmental Impact Assessment for the government’s Pacific Marine Industrial Zone in Madang paints a terrible picture of the likely social and environmental impacts of the project.

The 39-page EIS was prepared by the Department of Commerce and Industry in June 2010 and submitted to the Department of Environment and Conservation.

Although the EIS reveals local communities are “opposing the project”; the land clearance will have “significant human health and welfare implications”; the area “has immense significance in biodiversity, aesthetics and tourism”; and the land clearance work “will seriously affect local fishing grounds, nearby on-shore reefs and mangrove systems” which are home to globally endangered species, Environment Minister, Benny Allen, last week approved the project.

The EIS says local communities oppose the project because of issues over “land, participation and environment degradation” and these socio-cultural issues “could eventually undermine the economic viability of the project”. Local communities, say the EIS, argue the land for the PMIZ was “acquired fraudulently” by RD Tuna and the government.

The EIS says labor importation will be needed to meet scheduled goals and objectives. People from within PNG and abroad will work within the project. Health issues may include STDs and HIV/Aids, typhoid, cholera and dysentery and conflicts between local communities and imported workers. The PMIZ will lead to an increase in squatter settlements and encroachment onto customary land.

Other human and health risks disclosed in the EIS include sewerage spills; loss of subsistence use of land, recreation and local economic opportunities; destruction of cultural sites, tourism potential and aesthetic values; and transmittable diseases.

The EIS reveals local women are already “forced to exchange sex for fish” and the PMIZ will increase this problem. At the existing RD tuna cannery, “employment conditions for local workers are poor” and local communities say the factory has not brought tangible benefits.

The EIS describes Madang lagoon as the largest and most ecologically diverse on this stretch of coast – which is known to be a hot-spot for marine benthic invertebrates. The lagoon has an unusually rich biodiversity and is “conservatively estimated” to contain 700 species of coral and 1,000+ species of reef fish.

An amazing variety of new marine species have been discovered in and around Madang lagoon in recent years, broadening our knowledge of fishes, soft and hard corals, nudibranchs, flatworms, polychete worms, sea stars, feather stars, amphipods and sea cucumber to name a few.

The EIS says there are two endemic species of fish and two globally endangered fish species in the area. Also two species of globally endangered turtles have been sighted in the project area. The EIS says the lagoon is home to three endangered mammal species. On land, four fauna species are listed in CITES Appendix 2 – rainbow lorikeet, eclectus parrot, freshwater crocodile and lizard.

The EIS covers the site development activities only and not the construction of the planned industrial factories and facilities.

The PMIZ will eventually include a wharf and pier, fish port and canneries, cold storage facility, fuel depot, roads, residential complex, water treatment and electricity plants, container terminal and administrative buildings.

PORT MORESBY, 16 March 2011 (IRIN) – Government officials in Papua New Guinea’s national health department have received massive kickbacks from pharmaceutical drug suppliers in a scandal that had been going on for nearly 10 years, but moves are afoot to tackle the problem, health officials say.

Payments by medical suppliers to government officials for favours had run into the equivalent of hundreds of thousands of dollars, said the head of the country’s National Health Department (NDOH), Clement Malau, as well as senior hospital officers.

http://www.actnowpng.org/content/latest-log-export-data accessed 28 Mar

Latest log export data

The latest round log export data from SGS shows that Papua New Guinea exported 3 million cubic metres of round logs in 2010, almost a 50% on 2009.

China remains the main export destination, increasing its export share from 83% in 2008 and 2009 to 86% in 2010.

Year Quantity m3 Value US$ China vol China %
2008 2,584,298 189,950,784 2,152,577 83
2009 2,093,193 169,933,857 1,743,156 83
2010 2,999,467 272,030,754 2,574,164 86

http://pipelinesinternational.com/news/construction_set_to_commence_on_png_lng_pipeline/055345/ accessed 28 Mar

Construction set to commence on PNG LNG Pipeline

An international consortium is set to bring Papua New Guinea’s vast onshore petroleum resources to market, with the construction of an 850 km, large-diameter pipeline. Pipelines International spoke with the operator Esso Highlands to get the latest.

Construction activities are ramping up on the Papua New Guinea (PNG) LNG Project moving into the second quarter of 2011. Linepipe for the onshore gas pipeline has been arriving at the expanded shore base at Kopi, and clearing of the pipeline right-of-way has commenced. The manufacture of linepipe, including internal coating and concrete weight coating, is complete for the offshore section of the pipeline.

The project involves a two-train, 6.6 MMt/a LNG processing facility, and the integrated development of the Hides, Angore and Juha gas fields, as well as associated gas from the Kutubu, Agogo, Gobe and Moran oil fields.

The gas will be transported to the LNG plant near Port Moresby through approximately 850 km of onshore and offshore large diameter pipeline.

The onshore pipeline and affiliated infrastructure will be built by a French company Spiecapag. The onshore section will consist of a buried pipeline overland from Hides gas plant to the Omati River landfall, a distance of approximately 300km

Construction of the offshore pipeline will be undertaken by Italian company Saipem.  The work includes transportation and installation of 407km, 34 inch diameter subsea gas pipeline from the omati River landfall point on the southern coast of PNG to the onshore point near Port Moresby, where the LNG plant will be located.

Due to PNG’s extreme undulating terrain, an airport is being constructed at Komo in the SHP in a join venture between McConnel Dowell and Consolidated Contractors.

The runway will be 3.2 km long, which compares with the length of major international airports – Heathrow’s longest runway is 3.9km.

The length of the runway is because it will be receiving Antonov AN-124 aircrift that will be bringing in materials for the PNG LNG upstream facilities over a six-month period.  In the long term, Dash-8 aircraft will be the most frequent users of the airport.

The LNG Project is expected to deliver its first LNG shipments by late 2013 or early 2014.  Joint venture participants include Eon Mobil subsidiary Esso Highlands as operator (33.2 per cent), Oil Search (29 percent), the PNG Government (16.6 percent), Santos (13.5 percent), Nippon Oil (4.7 percent), Mineral Resources Development (2.8 percent) and Petromin PNG Holdings Ltd (0.2 percent)).

TN 29 March 11: Revealing report on customary land

By JAYNE SAFIHAO
MORE than 2.6 million hectares of land have passed from customary landowners to non-indigenous companies in the last year, it has been revealed.
The Centre for Environmental and Community Rights (CELCOR) said in a report to the UN Human Rights Office that an ingenious manipulation of the special agricultural and business leases (SABL) arrangement, with the tacit support of land officers, now posed a significant threat to major tracts of customary land throughout the country.
Land transacted in this manner is taken from the traditional landowners for 99 years and has been described as worrisome by CELCOR.
This and other concerns were raised in a 90-page report presented to the United Nations Human Rights Office by CELCOR and four other non-governmental organisations during its 78th session of the committee on the elimination of racial discrimination last month.
The report highlighted the main purpose of the SABL and its intent with regards to the lease-lease back process, through which landowners by law are supposed to get their land  back unless a consent is given for a subsequent lease to a third party.
The report said such leases are still being abused by mining, logging and other companies.
“There is evidence and growing concern in PNG that the protections offered by the Land Act (1996) are not adequately observed and that the SABL process is increasingly being used to alienate customary land, in fact, if not in law.
“This is especially troubling given that the logging and mining sectors as a whole in PNG had been under scrutiny for wide-spread violations of human rights for many years.
“The number of SABLs granted by PNG has risen rapidly in the past year. When a SABL is issued it must, by law, be published in the national gazette.
“A review of the announced SABL issued by the government in the past 13 months (updated last January) reveals that no less than 2.6 million hectares of customary lands have been granted in SABL to non-indigenous companies and other entities.
“In this total of 68 leases or extensions to leases in the last year, the majority has been for 99 years despite the stated policy of the Lands and Physical Planning department that leases to non-indigenous entities over customary lands should be between only 10 years and 20 years,” the report said.
The matter is serious enough for PNG Ambassador to the UN, Robert Aisi, to take the matter personally to the UN Office of High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR).
Aisi pointed out the following poignant facts in his letter to the OHCHR:
* Indigenous lands under threat of alienation through the governments practice to issue SABL to non-indigenous companies as allowed by Land Act 1996;
* The acceleration of these SABL without seeking the consent of the landowners concerned as required under the same Act;
* The sidelining of landowners in these “sign off ceremonies”. Most do not know the purpose for which the land is acquired and the environmental damages planned by these companies;
* The alleged denial of access to judicial remedies by the Compensation (Prohibition of Foreign Legal Proceedings) Act (1996), to seek redress before foreign courts, including compensation for environmental destruction;
* The newly-amended Environmental Act 2010, which denies the people’s rights from seeking redress before national courts against environmental permits granted; and
* The NGO committee have urged the state to provide information to them on measures taken which will not result in a total land alienation exercise; that the state informs the landowners at all levels of consultations by which consent must be seen to be given and the fair representation in court in the case of any violation.
A response by Anwar Kemal, the Chairperson of the committee on the elimination of racial discrimination, one of the committees of the UN, has been given to the government to respond to these issues before July 31.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – February 2011

Social Concern – Notes from the News (February 2011)

Social Concerns Notes – February 2011

Post Courier 4 Feb: Medical supplies held up

By ROSALYN EVARA

THREE children are dead and many health centres adversely affected, some even closed, due to the prolonged closure of the Area Medical Store in Madang.
Amid this scenario health authorities are still awaiting funds to be released from the provincial government to hire vehicles to move medicines to the temporary store at PNG Maritime College.
Already calls have been made by concerned health workers and members of the public to authorities to urgently get the AMS up and running so that normalcy to services can be restored.
The AMS was closed several weeks ago by health inspectors with the town council after finding the building to be unsafe for human habitation.
Provincial authorities had, a fortnight ago, stated that all supplies would be moved to a temporary storage area while work started on a new building.
Acting director Paul Mabong confirmed the supplies were still in the run-down building at Modilon General Hospital grounds.
Mr Mabong said they they were waiting for funds from the provincial government to hire vehicles to transport the supplies.
Reporters were told that several deaths had been reported at Mugil Health Centre which is situated along the north coast.
The officer in charge of the health centre Sr Prisca Sual when contacted confirmed the deaths. She said three children were all under five. She said their deaths could be partly attributed to the closure of the AMS as it had resulted in them running out of all the basic drugs.
Sr Sual said to restock the clinic it would cost close to K11,000 just for the basics but that this was money the clinic did not have. She said despite this the clinic is still open and on standby.
“All the serious cases, we are referring to Modilon General Hospital while the minor ones are given precriptions to buy medicine from chemists in town.”

PNG Buying into mining operations

A 30% stake for the people of PNG in any new mining venture is not unusual or unreasonable. Indeed it is the very minimum we should be demanding. It is our gold, copper and nickel that is being mined after all and we deserve to see some of the profits boosting the public purse and being used for schools and health services etc.

A 30% stake is exactly what the government of Mekere Morauta negotiated with Highlands Pacific for the Ramu nickel mine in 2000.

But when the government of Michael Somare renegotiated the Ramu contract with the Chinese state-owned company MCC in 2006 it gave away that 30% stake – and gave the mine company a whole suite of other tax breaks on top.

Is the government about to sell us out to Nautilus Minerals just as it did with MCC?

Well, the answer to that question is yes, the government has sold out – just as it did with MCC and the Ramu nickel mine.

Instead of insisting the State be given a 30% stake in the mine – it is the State after all which is contributing the gold and copper that the mine will extract – the government has agreed that if it is to have a stake in the mine it will have to pay for it. Which means the government will have to give Nautilus US$27 million of tax payers money by February 15 and a further US$100 or more over the next three years as the mine is developed.

See: http://ramumine.wordpress.com/2011/02/04/revealed-how-deep-sea-mining-could-destroy-the-cradle-of-life-on-earth/ accessed 7 Feb, 2011

The National 4 Feb: ‘Cash royalties breed laziness’

DIRECTOR of Mamusi Advisory and Consultative Group (MACG) Benedict Lalepumanu has called on the government to reconsider laws on royalties, levies and grants payments to landowners because it is developing a handout culture.
Lalepumanu said spin-off benefits emanating from national projects should not be “in the form of straight cash handouts” as it would make landowners lazy to till the land thereby losing their “resourcefulness”.
“I think cash payments such as royalties, levies and business development grants, though good, can develop a type of handout mentality,” he said.
Lalepumanu, a principal landowner of the Mamusi constituency of Pomio, East New Britain, said that instead of giving money to the people in the form of grants and royalties, it should be invested in long-term projects such as schools, clinics, water, sanitation and roads.
“Money should also be invested in human resource development,” he said, adding that when gold, timber, gas or oil run out people would still push the province on.

Post Courier 4 February: K10m probe clears Baki

POLICE Department paid a helicopter company K5 million without following proper tendering process, according to an internal investigation report released to the Post-Courier yesterday.
This was part of the K10 million approved by Cabinet and paid by Finance Department to the police force to beef up security at the PNG LNG project areas. Police Commissioner Gari Baki was subsequently suspended because of the way the money was spent.
However, a separate inquiry ordered by Cabinet to investigate the K10m expenditure is understood to have cleared Mr Baki of any wrongdoing and recommended that further investigations be done to find out how the other K5 million was spent.
The Cabinet-ordered inquiry was carried out by Personnel Management Secretary John Kali, Public Employees Association President Michael Malabag, private businessman Alan Bird and former acting judge and constitutional lawyer Nemo Yalo.
The inquiry report was completed in four weeks and delivered to Chief Secretary Manasupe Zurenuoc on January 4 and tabled in Cabinet when Sam Abal was Acting Prime Minister. Mr Baki remains suspended.
Mr Baki’s term as police commissioner expired on January 4. Sources said last night Mr Baki had not been granted his natural justice if the inquiry cleared his name. Meanwhile, the police department’s internal audit section compiled a report detailing alleged misuse of funds from a trust account which held the K10 million.

A series of confidential reports from international consultancy firm Deloitte are highly critical of financial management within the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC).

In the first report, a review of ‘Finance Function Effectiveness‘, dated June 2008, Deloitte says that DEC’s Finance Branch complies with ‘almost none’ of the procedural requirements of the Public Finance Management Act or the Financial Management Manual and provides ‘no useful’ information to managers on spending against budget and work plans.

Review of expenditure for the first half of 2008 found 45% of total expenditure was not actually spent on conservation activities but on top management and administration, the Secretary and Ministerial services.

Deloitte found none of the Finance Branch staff had an accounting qualification and most had only completed Year 10 or 11 schooling. There was no manager or accountant employed in the Finance Branch.

Of 31 cash advance transactions tested in only 4 cases had there been any acquittal (a 13% compliance rate) and in one of those the amount due for reimbursement to DEC had not been settled.

No documentation for Overseas Travel Advances could be found. In the first six months of 2008 these advances totaled K158,000. This is described as a ‘major failing in record keeping and leaves DEC unable to ascertain whether misappropriation has occurred’.

Asset registers were woefully outdated, the oldest had not been updated for 13 years and the most recent for 8 years.

Only 2 of 22 tested transactions contained all the required authorization signatures (a 9% compliance rate).

Security bonds paid to a hire car company had not been refunded to DEC and the extent of the losses not monitored.

DEC Secretary, Wari Iamo, is no stranger to allegations of financial mismanagement and corruption. Ten years ago it was revealed that what was then the Office of Environment & Conservation (OEC), spent over K 150,000 at the Maggi seafood restaurant within a period of 9 months.  It is believed that the receipts were used for ‘double-dipping’ in which the restaurant was really paid less than the invoiced amount, with the balance being returned to OEC staff. This was exposed in a television documentary, and also in local newspapers but when his Minister tried to initiate disciplinary proceeding against Iamo, the Minister was sacked by the Prime Minister, Michael Somare.

Post Courier 7 Feb: K112m misused

A total of K112 million was paid out by the Department of Planning and Monitoring under political directions to shore up Government support in the face of a no-confidence motion against Prime Minister Sir Michael Somare.
This was revealed in a letter written by the departmental head Mr Joe Lelang to his Minister Mr Paul Tiensten on December 6, 2010 wherein he said political directions were issued to his department to “honour certain government commitments … to shore up coalition numbers in view of the imminent vote of no confidence that was expected in the November session of Parliament.”
“The department was advised to find the money and make necessary payments irrespective of its source (where the money was coming from)”, wrote Lelang.
Post-Courier understands that Mr Lelang wrote to Mr Tiensten to explain the payments upon learning that Finance and Treasury Minister Peter O’Neil and other senior Ministers in Government were pushing for his suspension.
“On 12th August, 2010, the department was directed by Minister for Public Service and Acting Minister for Finance and Treasury Hon. Peter O’Neill at the Havana Club (in the presence of yourself and Hon. Patrick Pruaitch) to release K51 million under the Development Budget … ,” he told Mr Tiensten.
Mr Lelang said upon receiving the direction, the department released K51m worth of cheques as follows:
* Kokoda High School K3.0 million (Sohe District Treasury)
* Kokoda Roads K3.0 million (Sohe District Treasury)
* Rai Coast Bridge K3 million (Rai Coast District Treasury)
* Agro Estate Development Project K10.9 million (Teariki Holdings Limited)
* Transgogol High School K3 million (Madang District Treasury)
* Growth Centre K2 million Ialibu-Pangia (Ialibu-Pangia District Treasury)
* East New Britain Provincial Town Roads K5 million (ENB Provincial Treasury)
* Cocoa Pod Borer Aitape K6 million (Trust Account)
* Kimbe Town Roads K5 million (WNB Provincial Treasury)
* Vanimo Police K2 million (Vanimo District Treasury)
* Chuave Hospital Refurbishment K2 million (Chuave District Treasury)
* Nigerum Bridge North Fly K3 million (North Fly District Treasury)
* Palmalmal High School Upgrading K4 million (Pomio District Treasury)
“In addition, upon direction from yourself and Minister Arthur Somare, K33 million was raised for presentation by the Prime Minister at the inauguration of Hela Province in the Southern Highlands,” wrote Lelang.
He said that K33m was divided as – K10m for Tari power supply and K23m for Hela infrastructure development.
“Again from political directions,” wrote Lelang, “a total of K28m was paid to 14 provincial governors when in fact under the PSIP for 2010 budget, governors are only entitled to K1m. There were excessive payments of K14m in this instance,” wrote Lelang.
“Therefore, a total of K98m was dished out on unbudgeted projects following directions by Minister for Finance and Treasury and Prime Minister’s office,” he said. Funds were drawn from District Services improvement Program, Infrastructure Development Grants and Business Development Grants.
The no-confidence motion was never tabled in the Parliament in November last year following the withdrawal of four MPs who had originally signed the motion. The motion was to have been tabled again during the January session for the election of Governor-General but the Opposition was unable to find the Acting Speaker Francis Marus and hand-deliver the notice of motion as required by standing orders of Parliament.
FINANCE and Treasury Minister Peter O’Neill has brushed aside claims by National Planning secretary Joseph Lelang that a total of K112 million was paid out to shore up government support in the face of a vote of no-confidence against the Somare government.
He described the comments as “misleading and irresponsible”

The National 8 Feb

MP calls for tougher laws on sale of alcohol

THE member for Moresby Northeast Andrew Mald has called on the national government and the National Capital District Commission to critically look into the liquor business after the rise in alcohol-related deaths in the city.
A concerned Mald said after learning of the shooting to death of Akuila Emil, a former Kumul player from New Ireland, who was alleged to have been killed by a highly- educated national outside a hotel after his (Emil’s) car bumped into the alleged killer’s vehicle.
Mald said such alcohol-related incident was not the first of its kind as many incidences and similar killings in the city in recent times had been alcohol-related.
He said tougher laws were needed to control alcohol trading and consumption to control the escalating deaths and crimes that were directly related to the abuse of alcohol.
He said trading hours at night clubs should be regulated and also all liquor trading in settlement and residential areas should be shut down and  tougher penalties should be imposed on offenders.
He said all night clubs should sell liquor until midnight and any extension should result in the licences be terminated while all beer outlets in settlements and residential areas should be banned.
He added that all drivers caught under the influence of alcohol must have the licences immediately suspended.
He said tough measures were necessary because many prominent and well-educated people who were the agents of the nation’s development were dying or killed as a result of prolonged drinking and drunken behaviour in the society.
“Residents in Port Moresby were using and consuming alcohol as if it is just fun and in many of these situations the drinkers do not exercise moderation.
“They drink like there is no tomorrow,” he said.
Mald said business was good for those that traded alcohol but the cost to the country was far greater.
He added that besides loss of life, the cost to the economy, the cost of medical treatment, police investigation, and compensation demands and payments were excessive and serious.
“The NCDC must take advice seriously. As a commissioner, I will push for greater control and I also ask the government to also take immediate steps,” he said.
Mald has raised the concern on on the floor of parliament on several occasions but all that had fallen on deaf ears.

West Papuan refugees terrorised

Ash Pemberton

http://www.pngblogs.com/ accessed 9 Feb

West Papuan refugees in Papua New Guinea have been terrorised and arrested by police, West Papua Media Alerts said on January 28. They were allegedly arrested on behalf of the Indonesian military and local logging interests.

Police and soldiers rounded up 79 refugees living in camps around Vanimo, on PNG’s north coast near the border with West Papua, in the early hours of January 23.

The soldiers burned down at least 30 refugee houses, destroyed crops and food, and assaulted people, WPMA said. Other refugees have reportedly fled to the jungle.

Acting deputy police commissioner Fred Yakasa said anyone found not to be a PNG citizen would be considered an activist with the Free Papua Movement (OPM) and sent to the refugee camp at East Awin, Radio New Zealand International said on January 26.

About 12,000 West Papuan refugees live in PNG, WPMA said. They escaped from Indonesia’s repressive rule.

The OPM has struggled against Indonesian occupation for decades. Its armed wing, the National Liberation Army (TPN), has engaged in a low-level guerrilla war.

However, WPMA said the vast majority of those arrested are not believed to be OPM members.

The mass arrest of refugees is unprecedented, given PNG’s history of relatively tolerant behaviour towards West Papuans.

Refugees in PNG are usually allowed to work, but denied other rights as citizens, such as education and permanent housing. Many others cross the border regularly as it divides their traditional tribal lands, RNZI said on January 27.

The crackdown comes after the OPM signed an agreement with the PNG government in December to allow training in non-violent civil resistance techniques in the area, WPMA said.

However, the PNG government has used alleged activity by the TPN as an excuse for the arrests.

Spokesperson for the Blakwara refugee community Yalli Jikwa told WPMA: “The accusation that these villages were National Liberation Army training bases is completely false. These villages attacked have no connection at all to the TPN, and [PNG prime minister Sir Michael] Somare knows it.”

The United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) said it received official assurance that the refugees will not be forced to return to West Papua, RNZI said.

However, UNHCR’s Walpurga Englebrecht said it is not possible to be classed as both an OPM activist and a refugee, leaving their status in limbo.

The action by PNG authorities was part of “Operation Sunset Merona”, allegedly to protect local businesses by stopping the illegal shipment of goods into PNG by the Indonesian military.

It was also said to be aimed at stopping illegal workers employed by foreign logging companies operating at the border.

In January, a number of logging workers and Indonesian military personnel were arrested in raids on remote border camps and villages by PNG forces, WPMA said.

However, the switch to targeting refugees has led many to believe the operation is motivated by logging interests run by PNG elites and the Indonesian military.

It also follows the general pattern of harassment and intimidation of West Papuans carried out by Indonesia.

Most of the targeted refugee camps are in areas valuable for logging. The PNG government and business community also have a history of working closely with Indonesian interests to the detriment of ordinary people and the environment.

Secret diplomatic cables released by WikiLeaks have implicated the Indonesian military in illegal logging operations on both sides of the border. SMH.com.au said on December 23: “The Indonesian Military (TNI) has far more troops in Papua than it is willing to admit to, chiefly to protect and facilitate TNI’s interests in illegal logging operations.”

The action has angered many locals, who sympathise with fellow Papuans forced to live under brutal Indonesian rule.

Vanimo-based police units and army battalion refused to take part in the operation, which was run by forces from Port Moresby. WPMA said they cited resentment at working for Indonesian interests.

Governor of Port Moresby and long-time human rights activist Powes Parkop condemned the border operation in an open letter to Somare.

He called for the end of the operations, “as it is becoming obvious that our government and therefore police are being used by the Indonesian government to harass and suppress suspected West Papua activist campaigning for Independence of West Papua”. “This is morally and legally wrong.”
TN 9 Feb, letters: Bishop Reichart, SHP’s champ

BISHOP Stephen Reichart of Mendi diocese, who was recently promoted as the archbishop of Madang, was a faithful servant for the people of Southern Highlands.
He was the answer to the helpless voices of the disadvantaged in the nine districts where the government had neglected them for the past four decades.
He was a courageous and committed man who could fearlessly travel into fighting zones and initiate peace among warring tribes where no community leader or MPs dared to go.
Many leaders fled to Moresby or overseas when a major tribal fight broke out in Mendi town.
Business houses were destroyed and government services came to a halt but the bishop remained in the province through it all.
The fight, which claimed some 70 lives, came to an end when the bishop finally brokered a peace deal and brought the province back to normalcy.
People often urged the bishop to contest for the governor’s seat but he refused.
Bishop Reichart initiated many infrastructure developments and services like health, education, roads and other socio-economic development projects.
One of his most significant initiatives was to sponsor tertiary students struggling to meet all their fee requirements.
He relieved many parents during such crucial times and, by doing so, he has touched the hearts of all Southern Highlanders.
I cannot think of an appropriate word to describe Bishop Reichart’s noble work in Southern Highlands.
He was more than a priest or bishop.
I would say he was a champion of all trades.
I am happy to be a product of one of the schools he established in the province.
Thank you, Bishop Reichart.
May God reward you in heaven.

Michael Drake Kapu
Port Moresby

Post Courier 10 Feb: Kimbe hospital out of drugs

By Noel Pascoe

KIMBE Hospital in one of the nation’s prime growth areas has run out of essential, life-saving drugs and can’t get an answer to its dilemma.
West New Britain Governor Peter Humphries has flown to Port Moresby to try to unravel the medicine supply problem and says he is still waiting for answers from the Health Department.
Meanwhile, the hospital which caters to the capital of the nation’s oil palm industry has not had any resupplies of oxygen or halopaine, the substance used for anaesthetics, since November.
It has run out of the drugs to treat tuberculosis, a major worry for this deadly disease as successful treatment requires continued regular doses, without interruption.
“I’m appalled that the situation has reached this stage,’’ Mr Humphries said this week.
“I wouldn’t be surprised if there is a similar situation at other hospitals in Papua New Guinea. I’d like to see an inquiry into the purchasing and supplying of drugs.’’
Mr Humphries said the chief executive of the hospital Dr Victor Golpak had expressed his fears for the situation to him as governor, saying it was “a grave situation’’…..

http://www.canberratimes.com.au/news/world/world/general/uphill-battle-for-young-lives/2074226.aspx?storypage=1 accessed 14 Feb

Uphill battle for young lives

12 Feb, 2011

…. For every thousand babies born, 70 die before their fifth birthday. Five women die in childbirth daily but the figures vary. The official figure from the United Nations is 253 per 100,000 live births but it is as high as 733 in some areas. Consider Australia’s maternal mortality rate: 8.4 per 100,000 live births, meaning PNG’s rate is about 30 times that.

The persistently high maternal mortality rate arises from a complex web of factors: male ignorance and dominance; lack of health infrastructure in remote villages and provinces; high rates of HIV and AIDS and domestic violence; and a shortage of trained midwives.

This uphill battle to save the mothers and babies is mainly left to national organisations, dedicated voluntary bodies and philanthropists, international aid bodies such as AusAID, and churches.

Along with a lack of infrastructure and basic health services, one of the greatest impediments to saving maternal lives in PNG, particularly in rural communities, is the dearth of trained midwives.

“There is a serious, really serious lack of midwives,” Westaway says. “There’ve been a lot of words from the [PNG] government, a lot of moral support to take action, but … ” she trails off. …

Post Courier 16 Feb: K4 billion lost to fraud yearly

By TODAGIA KELOLA

THE country loses about 50 per cent of its Government budget directly to fraud.
That’s about K4 billion a year and on top of that Papua New Guinea fails to collect more than half of the taxation revenue that is due to it.
That’s from acting Deputy Police Commissioner Fred Yakasa yesterday when officially opening a workshop on Proceeds of Crime Act. …

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Social Concerns Notes – January 2011

Social Concerns Notes – January 2011

Democracy index: Papua New Guinea

 

The Economist Intelligence Unit’s 2010 Democracy index ranks Papua New Guinea (PNG) 59th out of 167 countries, a slight improvement from its position in the 2008 index, putting it among the countries classed as “flawed democracies”. This designation also includes Indonesia, the Philippines and Malaysia. Although elections in PNG are technically free, election related violence and electoral fraud are serious problems. Nevertheless, the election in 2007 demonstrated improvements in these areas, and was generally regarded as being one of the most peaceful in PNG’s history.

DemocracyIndex
Type Overall score Overall rank
2010 Flawed democracy 6.54 out of 10 59 out of 167
2008 Flawed democracy 6.54 out of 10 61 out of 167

Climate Change, by JAMES LARAKI of NARI

The 2010 United Nations Climate Change Conference held in Cancun, Mexico, reached important agreements, aimed at reducing the impacts of climate change.
The two-week long Cancun talks attended by more than 190 countries negotiated at length to reach agreements on the best possible ways to cut carbon emissions.
Such attempts made at the end of last year in Copenhagen ended in chaos and there were fears that the Cancun talks could failed again.
However, after two weeks of negotiating, rich and poor countries agreed a compromise that will see all countries committed to cutting emissions for the first time.
The outcome of the talks was an agreement which aims to limit global warming to less than 2 C above pre-industrial levels and calls on rich countries to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions as pledged in the Copenhagen Accord and for developing countries to plan to reduce their emissions.
The agreements oblige rich countries to contribute $30 billion in new aid over the next three years, growing the fund to $100 billion a year by 2020, to a Green Climate Fund.
This fund would help developing countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and mitigate climate change induced incidents such as floods, prolong dry periods and other factors that are likely affected livelihoods of the global poor.
While all nations are obliged to reduce emissions, how much will global emission be reduced and by when are some unanswered questions that negotiators continue to push them around.
And many commentators are of the view that the ambitions to keep the temperature raise at 2C may be nowhere near to prevent disasters that are likely to occur across the globe.
Important decisions on implementation of the cuts of emissions, how this burden will be shared between developed and developing countries, and how all this will be enforced have been once again pushed back by a year.
All these are likely to be considered at the next round of negotiations scheduled for December 2011 in Durban, South Africa.
Developing countries including Papua New Guinea are required under the agreement to device plans to reduce emissions and see best to benefit from the Green Climate Fund.
PNG, for example needs to understand how we fit into such agreements as the issue of climate change is of paramount to over 80% of the six million plus people.
We need to understand what would be done to achieve the required rate of reducing emission and whether the funding available could cater of the expected cuts.
While it is not clear what exactly rich countries are targeting by establishing this fund, reducing or minimising deforestation is obvious.
But deforestation may not work well for many developing nations including PNG who depend on it for income.
Many participants have cited the Cancun Agreements concerning REDD (Reductions in Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation) as another cause for optimism.
After all, deforestation causes roughly as many emissions globally as transportation does, and the Agreements pledge to give developing countries financial incentives to leave forests standing. If that has to happen, the incentives should march the likely income that would have come from harvesting forest.
Developing countries need to make a realistic approach to this and work out whether their expected income from harvesting forest can be compensated from the Green Climate Fund.
Such realistic figures could form the basis of negotiations and should help development of guidelines on how the fund is managed and disbursed.
In PNG, for example, it important that all concerned parties including resource owners should come up with plans to address the issue on hand.
Arguably the most important question left dangling after Cancun is the future of the Kyoto Protocol.
The advantage of Kyoto from a scientific perspective is that it imposes mandatory rather than voluntary emissions reductions, at least on rich nations; developing nations are exempted on the grounds that overcoming poverty must be their first priority.
Of course, the mandatory nature of Kyoto is precisely why the United States—alone among rich industrial countries—has refused to ratify it.
In Cancun, other rich nations signaled that they’ve had enough.
First Japan and then Russia and Canada announced they would abandon the protocol if other big emitters, the United States and China remained outside its purview.
The Cancun Agreements, however, may have opened a door to resolving this dispute, for they oblige all nations to reduce future emissions.
The challenge between now and next December in Durban is to translate that general principle into specific, proportional, binding targets for rich and poor countries alike and, much harder, generate the political pressure to compel national leaders to accept those targets.
PNG and other developing nations need to have an established leadership on climate change that is seen to be negotiating on their behalf at global forums like the Cancun talks.
Such leaderships are required as we need to play an active role in such talks as it stands us affect us all.
National Agriculture Research Institute (including other state agencies) and NGOs have developed initiatives aimed at increasing awareness, generation and adaptation of appropriate technologies to climate change, and reduce emissions.
With support from the national government, NARI is taking the lead in mitigating the impact of climate change on agriculture and food security.
All these initiatives and those of others need to be supported.
All concerned agencies need to come together and prepare PNG well to participate at Durban negotiations come December as the climate change scenario looks to be extremely dangerous and negotiations cannot go on forever.
In fact we shouldn’t be waiting so long to get started.

PNG Attitude: Analysing the PNG budget for 2010-11

BY MATTHEW MORRIS

MOST PAPUA NEW GUINEANS are simply trying to get by: earn a living, pay school fees, get medical care for loved-ones.

Many will also be wondering how, or if, their government will deliver critical services to help them along. The 2011 Budget provides some indications.

The budget of $3.5 billion is the country’s biggest yet and is equivalent to about K1,500 for each person in PNG. How confident are you that the government will use taxpayers money wisely? The rest of this article is based on publicly available data from PNG Treasury documents.

Economic growth. Before looking further at how to spend K1,500 per person, let’s take a quick look at the economic growth forecasts.

The good news is that the growth numbers in the budget documents are more or less consistent with the targeted 8.5% p.a. average growth between now and 2015 – making PNG probably the fastest growing economy in the Pacific.

But averages can be deceptive, and this average depends on the LNG project proceeding on schedule and a consequent 23% growth in 2015. Moreover, this growth will only benefit most people indirectly. And there is very little in the way of LNG tax revenues flowing by 2015.

So, from an individual perspective, it’s probably more relevant to focus on what is happening to non-mineral growth. The news is good. With forecast growth 4.6 % p.a. between now and 2015, non-mineral GDP per person that was just over K3,000 last year would reach K4,000 by 2015.

Mineral revenues. Turning to mineral revenues, the picture is mixed. The government collects revenue from the mineral sector through taxes and dividends, both forecast to fall sharply over the medium term. This is partly a reflection of Treasury’s tendency to be conservative in its forecasts, but there are other factors in play.

It is possible that the financing of the LNG project will impact on receipts, or perhaps Treasury is assuming the Ok Tedi mine will close. That might explain why mining and petroleum dividends, about K300m this year, disappear in 2013 and 2014.

Government spending. There are two perspectives on the level of spending. One is that spending is too high, and PNG should be running a budget surplus to mitigate the risk of revenue losses later and to deal with capacity constraints. The second view is that, with LNG revenues expected to come in 2018, and pressing development constraints, PNG needs to spend more now.

Both views have merit. The critical issue, though, is not whether to save or spend but how effectively to spend. Additional recurrent spending is welcome given the chronic underfunding of basic services in PNG, but are the extra resources getting to where they are needed?

Education. Education is a key basic service and accounts for 15% of total spending. The biggest increases were for non-teacher recurrent spending and the Development Budget, while the allocations for teacher salaries and provincial function grants got only a small increase.

While there was more money allocated to teacher salaries, this was only a tiny increase and falls a long way short of what the government has previously estimated is needed. Moreover, adjusted for inflation, funding for teacher salaries is flat, and lower than in previous years.

Based on this analysis, it is not clear where the funding will come from to pay for the extra teachers the government plans to recruit. Though, in the past, Treasury has pulled money for pay increases out of its miscellaneous allocation.

School fee subsidies, a topical issue at this time of year, will provide a 11% (real) boost for parents in 2011, but there are no increases thereafter. Given the challenges of service delivery in PNG and sharing mineral wealth, school fee subsidies are arguably the most effective way to indirectly reach the majority of Papua New Guineans.

Budget analysis. As the government prepares for a $31 billion inflow of LNG revenues, it is everybody’s business to check on how it is managing taxpayers money – starting with the K1,500 for each Papua New Guinean that will be spent this year. Will it deliver the services that people need?

Matthew Morris is a Research Fellow at the Crawford School and Deputy Director of the Development Policy Centre.

Source: Development Policy Newsletter, January 2011

Report on Violence and Insecurity in the Southern Highlands

From Oxfam.org.nz

This report presents the results of a study conducted in the Hela region of the Southern Highlands Province of Papua New Guinea over a 16-month period (October 2007 – March 2009). The study had the broad aim of exploring perceptions of insecurity, looking at the scale, nature, triggers and impacts of interpersonal and tribal violence. The main purpose of the study was to generate information for advocacy and to inform the policies and programme development of Oxfam and its local partner in the region, Hela Community Care.

Download report:http://www.oxfam.org.nz/resources/onlinereports/tari_report_final_dec6.pdf

PC 18 Jan 10: Police swoop on Barrick employees – Porgera

By JOSHUA ARLO

POLICE have begun arresting terminated employees of the Porgera Joint Venture (PJV) implicated in alleged sexual assaults against women and other serious crimes, with many more terminations and arrests expected in the coming weeks.
Acting Police Commissioner Tony Wagambie and PJV announ-ced this yesterday, stating that this is a result of a three-month investigation by a special police team set up last year by then Police Commissioner Gari Baki in the Porgera District and an internal investigation conducted by the PJV in line with the mine’s zero tolerance policy regarding employee behaviour of any kind of violence or human rights abuse against women and men.
Those terminated also include employees who knew about the assaults but failed to report to authorities, as well as those who allegedly misled investigators.
PJV said it expected its employees who saw or heard about such acts to immediately report to the appropriate authorities.
Mr Wagambie has warned he will not tolerate any kind of violent and criminal behaviour against women “on his watch” and perpetrators will be brought to justice.
“Enough is enough … These arrests send a strong warning to those who would assault the most vulnerable members of our communities – women and young people – that their actions will not be tolerated,” he said.
“The warning is clear – respect the human rights of others and follow the laws of this land, otherwise we will find you and we will bring you to justice without fear or favour.”
He said after receiving solid intelligence on these matters from the mine mangers of Barrick Gold and their independent investigators, the police moved in quickly to identify the alleged offenders.
“The mine took immediate actions after the disturbing results of an internal investigation into allegations of assaults and other serious crimes,” said Barrick executive general manager Mark Fisher in a joint statement from Barrick Gold Corporation and Mineral Resources Enga.
“We have terminated employees who were found to have breached out strict code of conduct regarding employee behaviour.”
He said PJV asked police to investigate when it received credible allegations in June last year. PJV also asked Ila Geno, the former Chief Ombudsman Comm-issioner and a former police commissioner to conduct an independent inquiry into alleged violence against women and report the findings directly to police.
Barrick also conducted a thorough internal investigation which involved a 15-member independent investigative team.
This team spent several months at the mine interviewing more than 650 employees and conducting a comprehensive investigation of staff and procedures.
“We have been working in close co-operation with the PNG police and we will continue to provide information and support to aid in their criminal investigation,” Mr Fisher said. “We condemn these alleged crimes in the strongest possible terms and wish to see anyone involved brought to justice under PNG law.”
Meanwhile, Mr Wagambie has revealed that investigations into other reported cases, including alleged abuses by police in the same area were continuing.
“No-one is above the law, even members for the Constabulary. Make no mistake – we are coming for them too. The best course of action for anyone who has information about these matters, or who has witnessed assaults or sexual assaults on women and young girls is to come forward now and report these matters to police. “Don’t be afraid to report these things – staying silent helps nobody.”

PNG powerbrokers snap up property (A view from Australia)

By: PAUL CLEARY

Australia is pressing regional countries to adopt tough anti-corruption standards

WHEN Papua New Guinea’s petroleum minister bought a Cairns McMansion in

2001, the deal was so “quick and easy” that the agent selling the property thought he was dealing with the wealthy owner of a coffee plantation. Despite buying in the depths of the global financial crisis, William Duma didn’t aggressively negotiate for a better price. He paid $585,000 for the 330sq m, five-bedroom, two-bathroom home with water views after securing the services of a Cairns agent to do the deal.

(The rest of the article available on request )

TN25 Jan : CEO: No plans for labour ward due to no funds

 By ALISON ANIS
PORT Moresby General Hospital chief executive officer, Sam Vegogo, said there are no immediate extension plans for the hospital including the maternity wing, which receives 40 to 50 visits a day from mothers, to its labour ward.
Vegogo said the focus currently was on major renovations to be carried out in specific sections of the hospital while expansion plans had been considered but could not be executed due to limited funding.
The labour ward has 23 beds for mothers during child labour but that hospital’s nursing staff have expressed concerns that space was lacking, considering the increase in number of mothers it had been receiving.
“We do about 30 deliveries in a day, on average.
“The labour ward is busy everyday with mothers coming from the city and even from villages in Central, so there is a need for extra beds in the ward,” a nurse at maternity wing said recently.
She said the something must be done at the wards 9, 10 and 11 of the maternity wing to ease the problem with overcrowding and with the many mothers sleeping on bare floors when they are admitted.
“We have considered major infrastructure to the hospital but these may not happen immediately.
“We have drafted the 2011-15 service improvement plan (SIP) which includes all clinical services and also infrastructure and starting 2012 budget we are looking at marginal increase that can be able to help us improve not only the building but the training of personnel staff or people to maintain these infrastructure,” Vegogo said.
The CEO added that the hospital’s SIP would be presented in March with the corporate plan.

The statistical nonsense coming out of PNG

BY JOHN BURTON

2010 Human Development Report, The Real Wealth of Nations: Pathways to Human Development, United Nations Development Program

PNG SCARCELY REPORTS a single statistical indicator accurately. This leads to nonsense in PNG’s entries in the Human Development Report (HDR) and a blank against many of the research topics ANU scholars pursue.

For PNG, the topic of food security is well-covered through national nutrition surveys, collaboration between researchers at the ANU, PNG’s National Agricultural Research Institute and elsewhere, and papers in the PNG Medical Journal.

Despite well-documented, localised food shortages, ‘daily calorie supply’, was reported for PNG at around 100% of requirements in HDRs in the 1990s. After 2000, ‘undernourished people as a % of total population’ took its place. This was reported at a belt-tightened 26-29% until 2004, then at a less serious value, and not at all from 2007.

Did Papua New Guineans feast through the 1990s only to starve in the 2000s? No, it is just any attention on the concept of ‘poverty’ in PNG is met with such populist outrage that it is awfully difficult to get empirical data from local reports into international ones.

Income poverty – living on less than $1.25 a day – was last reported in the HDR at 35.8% of the population (in 2009) and is now also missing from the current report…

PNG’s figures for life expectancy in the HDR are made up. The only calculations of life expectancy in PNG from nationally-collected data are those of the demographer Martin Bakker: 49.6 years and 54.2 years in the 1980 and 2000 censuses respectively. With the HIV-AIDS epidemic taking hold in PNG in the last decade, life expectancy might be going down again: we really have no idea.

The ‘decline’ of the maternal mortality ratio (deaths of women from pregnancy-related causes/100,000 live births) is another example of Dr Pangloss at work. The HDRs claim a remarkable fall in PNG, from 900 to 250 over the 20 years.

But with no death registration in PNG, where have the figures come from? They are also made up. Glen Mola of the Port Moresby General Hospital, PNG’s expert in these matters, currently accepts a figure of between 700 and 900, for an appalling lifetime risk for women of dying from pregnancy of 1 in 20. PNG has gone nowhere.

Who cares, or who should care, if a national government will not?

Donors. Their citizens may reasonably hope for some statistical evidence of their largesse, not idleness in the ministries that aid targets or, worse, a trowelling over of inconvenient discoveries. But even as ministers announced the aid priority for a statistical roadmap, the 2010 census was being undermined. The Census Office eventually conceded that the government had not allocated funds and has said it will try again next year.

Scholars. Many in the College of Asia and the Pacific, and their collaborators in national institutions in PNG, work hard in each of the HDR indicator areas. Other poor they have taken an interest in but who don’t feature in the 2010 HDR include refugees and victims of violence. Diana Glazebook could well be cross that the 2791 residents of the East Awin camps in the 2000 census – who haven’t gone anywhere – were reported as “0.0 thousands” in 2010. The contributors to Conflict and resource development in the Southern Highlands of Papua New Guinea will shake their heads to see the missing indicators on ‘conventional arms transfers’, homicide, robbery and assault rates.

International community. Helen Clark says in the foreword this year ‘not all the trends are positive, as we know too well’. She’s not kidding. If PNG had the health profile of Fiji – by no means an HDR saint – something like 8000 excess deaths among under fives and 1000 excess deaths of mothers would be saved in PNG, and with Fiji’s homicide rate, perhaps another 1000 murder victims, each year. These are big numbers – 350,000 avoidable fatalities since Independence, more than the population of Vanuatu, or Oro and New Ireland Provinces combined. But apart from Sweden, the only country to go backwards on the Human Development Index in 2010 was international whipping boy Zimbabwe. For the rest of the backsliders, PNG included, face was saved by simply not reporting bad news.

I like the HDR a good deal, but the international community owes it to the poor, the victimised and the needless dead to do a better job when governments contrive, by omission or commission, to erase them from statistical view.

Source: ‘HDR: a nearest neighbour analysis’ by John Burton, Development Policy Newsletter, January 2011

John Burton is a Research Fellow, Resource Management in Asia-Pacific Program, at the Crawford School, ANU.

 

Restriction on Global Fund Payments for PNG  (Yahoo News 26 Jan 11)

GENEVA (AFP) – The head of the Global Fund Against AIDS, TB and Malaria on Monday pledged “zero tolerance” for corruption following reports that it was dealing with cases that had prompted donor nation Sweden’s concern.

“The global fund has zero tolerance for corruption and actively seeks to uncover any evidence of misuse of its funds,” said Michel Kazatchkine, the Fund’s executive director, underlining that its anti-fraud controls were “most rigorous”.

Kazatchkine said the cases of corruption reported in the media over the weekend were not new and had already been revealed by the Fund last year on its website, and acted on. They involved “grave misuse” of about 34 million dollars for projects in Djibouti, Mali, Mauritania and Zambia that had gone missing in the four African countries, he explained.

Kazatchkine said the Fund had recovered 19 million dollars so far.

The Fund revealed last June that it had suspended aid to Zambia pending action by local authorities on fraud.

Kazatchkine said Monday that criminal proceedings were underway there as well as in Mali and Mauritania, but he did not mention Djibouti.

A top prosecutor in Mali said in September that several health ministry officials had been arrested during a probe into embezzlement from the Fund.

The Fund has imposed additional restrictions on cash transfers, while the safeguards were also in place for Ivory Coast and Papua New Guinea.

A Swedish newspaper reported on Saturday that Sweden had told Kazatchkine that it would not commit to its 167 million euro contribution to the fund unless more was done to ensure that cash is not siphoned off.

“Sweden did not say that it would withdraw,” Kazatchkine told journalists.

“On the contrary I came back Friday evening from Stockholm with the statement that Sweden would contribute and would increase its constributions to the Fund,” he added.

The UN-backed agency provides grants for selected projects against the three diseases in poor nations, allocating money provided by governments and private donors such as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

“In his report last year, the Global Fund inspector general listed grave misused of funds in four of the 145 countries which receive grants from the Global Fund,” Kazatchkine said. “In total the Global Fund is demanding the recovery of US 34 millions dollars unaccounted in these countries out of a total disbursement of 13 billion dollars.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment